Patrick Maughan, a 27-year-old with a history of violent crimes including rape and sexual assault, was sentenced to an additional two years in custody for stealing a mobile phone during a robbery in Terenure. The victim, a 64-year-old care assistant, was attacked by Maughan and his accomplice, who later fled the scene. The phone was later recovered from Maughan, who was found in a critical condition at the police station. The court considered the severity of the attack, the impact on the victim, and Maughan's extensive criminal record. The judge noted that the sentence would run consecutive to Maughan's existing 13-year sentence. The victim described the lasting physical and emotional effects of the assault, including ongoing pain and a diminished sense of security. Patrick Maughan pleaded guilty.
Anthony Cooney, a 38-year-old chronic drug addict, was jailed for nine and a half years for two violent car hijackings. During the first incident, Cooney held a knife to the throat of a 70-year-old woman and threatened to kill her. In the second, he used a fork to threaten a couple, stabbing the driver and demanding money. The stolen car was later involved in a collision with a commercial van, causing significant damage. Cooney was arrested at the scene and was too intoxicated to be interviewed. He later admitted to the hijacking and apologized. The judge noted the severity of the offenses and the trauma inflicted on the victims, emphasizing that Cooney's actions were deplorable and required a long prison sentence. Cooney was also disqualified from driving for eight years.
Derek Boyd, 31, of Finglas, Dublin 11, and Chantelle Harcourt, 34, of Darndale, Dublin 17, are currently on trial at the Central Criminal Court. Boyd has pleaded not guilty to the murder of Mark Carroll, 34, at his home on June 9, 2024, and to assaulting Megan Rock. Harcourt has pleaded not guilty to impeding the apprehension or prosecution of the person who committed the murder. The jury, comprising seven men and five women, began deliberating on Monday afternoon and has spent five hours over two days in the jury room. On Monday evening, the foreman reported that the jury had not reached a verdict on any of the three counts. Ms Justice Melanie Greally adjourned the deliberations, instructing the jurors to return to court at 10.30am the following morning. In her charge, the judge warned the jury against using Boyd's previous conviction for the manslaughter of his sister to infer a propensity for violence, labeling such reasoning impermissible. She clarified that this prior conviction, for which Boyd was sentenced to five years with three suspended, may only be considered if relevant to the evidence, such as his state of mind or flight from the jurisdiction. The judge outlined the legal framework for self-defense under the Criminal Law (Defence and the Dwelling) Act 2011, emphasizing the requirement for proportionate force. The jury may return verdicts of guilty of murder, not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter, or not guilty for Boyd, and guilty or not guilty for Harcourt.
A prisoner who attempted to shoot Gerry the Monk's brother has been sentenced for possessing drugs in prison. Michael Carroll, serving a 22-year sentence for attempted murder, was jailed for two counts of possessing cannabis and heroin for supply in his cell. The drugs, concealed between his legs, had a combined value of €3,720. Carroll, who has 54 previous convictions, claimed the drugs did not belong to him and were held for others due to a drug debt. He has completed violence prevention courses and is involved in restorative justice. Judge Orla Crowe noted the egregious nature of the offence and the high number of previous convictions. She reduced the headline sentence of three years to two years, taking mitigating factors into account. Carroll's current release date is in 2038. Michael Carroll pleaded guilty.
Ibrahim Ahmed Gharib, a violent rapist who was released from a 10-year sentence in 2024, raped another woman just a year later. Gharib was found guilty of raping and sexually assaulting Christina Foley in a builders' shed in Dublin. The victim was arrested while trying to report the incident at a garda station and later suffered from anxiety and trauma. Gharib had previously been jailed for 10 years in 2018 for raping a student. The court heard that Gharib had a history of criminal behaviour and was released in January 2024. The victim, who waived her anonymity, expressed the impact of the crime on her life and thanked the gardaí and legal team for their support. Gharib's defence argued that he did not accept the verdict but acknowledged the victim's vindication. The court will sentence Gharib later this month.
Paolo Nascimento, who murdered Grainne Dillon in 2002, is challenging the State's refusal to transfer him to Portugal to care for his ill mother. Nascimento, currently on parole, seeks an order from the High Court to quash the Parole Board's refusal to transfer his sentence. Portugal imposes a fixed 25-year sentence for murder, as opposed to Ireland's life sentence with potential for parole. The Parole Board has refused the transfer three times since 2006 due to Portugal's lack of post-release monitoring. Nascimento's legal team argues that the refusal violates his rights as an EU citizen and prevents him from reuniting with his family. The High Court granted leave to challenge the refusal and adjourned the matter to November. Nascimento's mother, his closest living relative, is too sick to travel to Ireland, and he seeks a declaration that the Parole Board unlawfully fettered its discretion. Paolo Nascimento pleaded guilty.
An Algerian national, Mohamed Hallam, has been jailed for six years for a violent predatory sexual attack on a young woman in Donegal. Hallam, who moved to Ireland in 2023, was convicted of sexual assault, assault causing harm, and non-fatal strangulation. The victim, who was heavily intoxicated, was attacked in a dark alleyway after meeting Hallam in a nightclub. She described being choked, pinned down, and sexually assaulted. The court heard that she had bruises and a possible bite mark on her stomach. Hallam initially denied the charges but later accepted the jury's verdict. The judge reduced the headline sentences due to mitigating factors, including Hallam's acceptance of guilt. The victim's impact statement detailed the lasting trauma she experienced. Hallam was ordered to undergo post-release supervision and engage in psychological counselling and a sex offender treatment programme.
Patrick Fishy' Fitzgerald, 49, withdrew his appeal against a seven-year prison sentence at the Court of Appeal after judges warned him of the full range of their powers. The appeal concerned a sentence handed down in July 2025 by Ms Justice Eileen Creedon at the Central Criminal Court. Fitzgerald had pleaded guilty to facilitating a serious offence for a criminal organisation, specifically providing getaway vehicles for the attempted murder of Gary Carey in November 2021. The court found his assistance crucial to the gang's actions. Ms Justice Creedon set a headline sentence of 12 years, reduced to nine years after mitigation, with the final two years suspended subject to conditions. This term was ordered to run consecutively to a separate seven-and-a-half-year sentence Fitzgerald was already serving for aggravated burglary, in which he was part of a gang that terrorised a family, including a six-year-old child. During the appeal hearing, Mr Justice McCarthy, sitting with Ms Justice Tara Burns and Mr Justice Alexander Owens, noted the panel believed a sufficient reduction had already been given and highlighted the risk regarding the suspended portion. Following advice from senior counsel Bernard Condon, Fitzgerald instructed his lawyer to seek permission to withdraw the appeal. The court granted the application, describing Fitzgerald's decision as prudent given the possibility of an unfavourable intervention. The matter was adjourned to allow for the withdrawal process, and the original sentence remains in effect.
A 59-year-old man from Co Galway was jailed for six years after being found guilty of raping and indecently assaulting his younger sister when she was a child. The victim, now in her late 40s, described the abuse as 'torture' and told her brother he 'ruined her life'. The jury convicted him on two counts, but could not agree on 21 other charges, which the DPP will not retry. The man denied all charges and has 24 previous convictions. The court heard that the abuse occurred in their family home, and the brother told the victim her mother would die if she told anyone. The victim's impact statement highlighted the lasting trauma and shame she experienced. The judge sentenced him to seven years for rape and five years for indecent assault, with both sentences to run concurrently. The defence argued the man should be treated as a minor at the time of the offence and that the jury's inability to agree on most charges should be considered.
The High Court has rejected arguments against the extradition of Jonathan Gill to Northern Ireland to face a murder charge related to the killing of Robbie Lawlor. Mr Justice Patrick McGrath did not issue an extradition order but remanded Gill in custody until July 29. Gill is accused of participating in a joint enterprise to murder Lawlor in 2020 as part of a gang feud. His lawyers argued that the UK courts would not provide the same protections as the Court of Justice of the European Union regarding evidence from the Encrochat system. However, the judge said the UK legal system would ensure a fair trial. Gill remains in custody, having previously been denied bail. The court will consider the extradition order after Gill and his legal team have time to review the judgment.
A teenager with 30 previous convictions who was caught on CCTV stamping on an unidentified man's head and using a bicycle as a weapon during a group attack has been jailed. Adam Farrell pleaded guilty to assaulting an unknown person with intent to cause bodily harm. The court heard that the victim left the scene after the assault and gardai have been unable to identify him. Farrell's defense highlighted his difficult background, including a leg injury and the loss of an older brother. The judge noted the viciousness of the attack and sentenced Farrell to two and a half years' imprisonment, with the final 12 months suspended. The ruling underscores the seriousness of the assault and the need for accountability, despite the lack of a formal complaint from the victim.
A former teenager with 81 previous convictions who was on bail when he punched a homeless man in a 'cowardly, savage attack', causing serious injuries, has been jailed for six years. Shane Murray, then 19, assaulted Damien Merrigan on a Dublin street three years ago but fled the country after being identified. Mr Merrigan, who was homeless, died in July 2025. The court heard that major force was required to fracture the skull and facial bones. Murray pleaded guilty to assault causing serious harm in 2023. Judge Jonathan Dunphy noted the unprovoked nature of the attack and that the victim was vulnerable. The judge inferred that an implement was used, and that Murray left the scene, highlighting a disregard for the victim and the criminal justice system. The judge accepted Murray's expression of remorse and suspended the final two years of the eight-year sentence on strict conditions. Murray has a difficult background, including addiction issues and a history of drug offences.
The trial of Derek Boyd, 31, and Chantelle Harcourt, 34, continues before the Central Criminal Court. Mr Boyd has pleaded not guilty to the murder of Mark Carroll, 34, at his home in Finglas on June 9, 2024, and to assaulting Megan Rock. Ms Harcourt has pleaded not guilty to an offence of impeding the apprehension or prosecution of a person. In closing submissions, the prosecution alleged that Mr Boyd carried out a determined, murderous attack on Mr Carroll, who had returned to the house to resolve a previous row. The defence argued that Mr Boyd acted out of instinct to protect himself against a trespasser who was threatening him. The jury heard that Mr Boyd was serving the suspended portion of a sentence for the manslaughter of his sister at the time of the alleged offence. The defence counsel suggested that Mr Boyd's subsequent departure to the UK was motivated by the threat of returning to prison for that prior conviction. The trial is ongoing and has not been finalised; it is scheduled to continue on Monday before Ms Justice Melanie Greally and a jury.
The Court of Appeal has quashed the defilement conviction of a 34-year-old man, directing a retrial after finding the trial judge "crossed a line" in his jury charge. The appellant, who was 28 at the time of the alleged 2020 offence in Westport, had been convicted by majority verdict of defilement of a 16-year-old girl, while being acquitted of sexual assault. He maintained that he believed the complainant was over 18. Ms Justice Nuala Butler ruled that the trial judge improperly suggested the jury might take a "jaundiced" view of the appellant's age defence if they rejected his claim that no sexual intercourse occurred. This misdirection deprived the appellant of the benefit of his alternative defence. The court rejected a secondary appeal ground regarding the prosecution's use of the term "Bart Simpson defence," deeming it unhelpful but not sufficiently disparaging to render the trial unfair. In November 2025, Judge Eoin Garavan had sentenced the man to two years in prison, with the final 12 months suspended and the custodial element deferred, granting him bail pending appeal. Following the appeal decision, Eilis Brennan, for the Director of Public Prosecutions, requested the matter be remanded to the Western Circuit in early October. The judge granted this application, remanding the appellant on continuing bail until that date.
Derek Boyd, 31, took the stand at his murder trial before Ms Justice Melanie Greally. He admitted to previously pleading guilty to his sister's manslaughter and stated he was serving part of that suspended sentence when the incident occurred. Boyd pleaded not guilty to murdering Mark Carroll, 34, at his home in Finglas on June 9, 2024, and to assaulting Megan Rock. His partner, Chantelle Harcourt, 34, pleaded not guilty to impeding the apprehension of the offender. Boyd testified that he picked up a knife to deter Carroll, who he alleged threatened to kill him, and swung it during a struggle without intent to injure. Prosecution counsel Sean Guerin SC cross-examined Boyd on his prior firearm-related manslaughter conviction and alleged he exaggerated Carroll's threats. The judge directed a not guilty verdict on the count of threatening to kill Megan Rock due to insufficient evidence. The trial continues tomorrow.
A violent criminal, Colm Carroll, has been jailed for four years after pleading guilty to two counts of assault causing harm to his then partner. Despite his guilty plea, Carroll disputed the facts of the case and claimed he also received injuries during the incident. Judge Sheahan described the attack as 'horrific' and noted that the victim remains deeply traumatised. The court considered aggravating factors, including Carroll's previous convictions, his being on bail at the time, and the incident occurring within an intimate relationship. The judge acknowledged Carroll's genuine remorse and took into account his guilty plea, family support, and efforts to address his addiction. A five-year sentence was imposed, with the final 12 months suspended on strict conditions. The court directed Probation Services to engage with Carroll before his release to ensure he continues addressing his addiction. The incident involved Carroll kicking and punching his partner while demanding money, leading to severe injuries and long-term trauma for the victim.
Jozef Puska has failed in his attempt to have his life sentence for the murder of Ashling Murphy commence from the date of his arrest in January 2022, rather than the date of the trial jury's verdict in November 2023. Puska's legal team argued that the judge did not provide a valid reason for not backdating the sentence. However, the trial judge, Mr Justice Tony Hunt, stated that the backdate was academic and that the parole board would consider the time served in custody, not the date of arrest. The Court of Appeal upheld the judge's decision, noting that the judge had considered the seriousness of the case and the impact on the victim's family. The appeal was dismissed, and Puska remains in custody.
A woman with 218 previous convictions, including 15 for breaching domestic violence orders, has been jailed for two months after breaching a barring order and refusing to leave her mother's home. The woman, who is in her 40s, pleaded guilty to breaching the order at her mother's south Dublin home on June 29. The case was heard in camera, with the defendant's mother having obtained the barring order in October 2025 after previous assaults. The woman remained at her mother's home for three days, during which her mother saw her drinking and became concerned about potential violence. The court heard that the woman had been working full-time and was sober for nine months before the breach. However, her mental health deteriorated after she stopped taking her prescribed medication and began drinking again. Judge Anne Watkin noted the woman's 16th breach of a domestic violence order and sentenced her to two months in prison, taking into account her guilty plea and the time already spent in custody.
Derek Boyd, 31, pleaded not guilty to the murder of Mark Carroll, 34, at a Finglas home on June 9, 2024, and to threatening and assaulting Megan Rock. His partner, Chantelle Harcourt, 34, pleaded not guilty to impeding the prosecution of an arrestable offence. The Central Criminal Court trial heard that Boyd was serving a suspended sentence for the 2022 manslaughter of his sister, Sandra Boyd, and unlawful possession of a firearm. He received a four-year sentence for manslaughter, with the final two years suspended, and a concurrent five-year sentence for firearm offences, with the final three years suspended. The court noted he was under active supervision when Carroll died. The prosecution alleges Boyd stabbed Carroll with intent to kill or cause serious harm. Boyd claimed self-defence, stating Carroll lunged at him. Evidence detailed Carroll's history, including a guilty plea to assaulting Rock in Ashbourne, Co Meath, where she was found bruised and shaking, and a pending charge for assaulting a man in Dublin 7 in 2022. The trial continues before Ms Justice Melanie Greally.
Austin Byrne, a 49-year-old man with a long history of criminal convictions, was involved in a violent incident at Wheatfield Prison and two burglaries in Dublin 2. Byrne stole €20,000 worth of property from two unoccupied homes, including items of sentimental value. During the incident at the prison, he struck another man with a brush handle six times, though he claimed he attempted to de-escalate the situation. Byrne has 98 previous convictions, including multiple burglaries and assaults. He is currently serving a three-year and six-month sentence. The court heard that the burglaries were poorly executed and likely motivated by Byrne's drug addiction. Victim impact statements were submitted, but no property was recovered. Byrne's defense acknowledged his long criminal history and expressed a desire to address his addiction. The judge noted the seriousness of Byrne's actions and ordered urine analysis before adjourning the case. Austin Byrne pleaded guilty.
Jamie O'Brien, a 32-year-old serial burglar, was jailed for three years with the final six months suspended for burglarizing staff lockers at a Dublin restaurant. O'Brien was identified by CCTV and arrested after fleeing the scene. He has 46 previous convictions, including 12 for burglary, and was on bail at the time of the offense. The court heard that O'Brien had significant mental health issues and was abusing drugs at the time. His defense highlighted his guilty plea and unreserved apology. The judge considered the mitigating factors and imposed a three-year sentence. O'Brien has a history of burglary, including a ten-year sentence in 2017 for the burglary, assault, and false imprisonment of an elderly woman. The court also noted that no property was recovered from the restaurant, and no victim impact statements were made.
A Ukrainian woman accused of committing burglaries in south Dublin, including one at the home of a 99-year-old woman, has been refused bail. The woman, who is in her 30s and of no fixed abode, faces multiple charges, including two burglaries, unlawful entry into a vehicle, trespassing, and an alleged assault on a garda. Judge Anne Watkin described the allegations as serious and violent, noting the woman's conduct during the hearing and her likelihood to reoffend. The court heard that the woman allegedly confronted occupants at a residence, grabbed them by the throat, and demanded money. She is also accused of assaulting Garda Odhran Boyle during her arrest. The judge refused bail under Section 2 of the Bail Act, citing the seriousness of the charges and the risk of reoffending. The woman is due to appear again for directions from the Director of Public Prosecutions.
Shane Murray, a teenager with 81 previous convictions, was on bail when he punched a homeless man, leaving him with fractures to his skull and face. Murray assaulted Damien Merrigan on a Dublin street in 2023, but left the country after gardai identified him. Merrigan remained in hospital for seven days and later died in 2025. Murray pleaded guilty to assault causing serious harm. CCTV footage showed Murray placing something on his hand before the assault. He was identified from CCTV and returned voluntarily in 2024. His defence highlighted his troubled background, including a lack of a father figure and drug use. The prosecution argued for a sentencing range of ten to 15 years due to the unprovoked nature of the assault and the use of an implement. The defence requested a lower sentencing range. Murray's mother was in court to support him. Judge Jonathan Dunphy adjourned the case until Friday to consider the sentencing.
A man with no previous convictions who was in a cannabis-induced psychosis when he stabbed his childhood friend in the back during a bizarre attack has had the balance of his jail sentence suspended. Neal Brennan, 29, pleaded guilty to assault causing harm to Cian Brennan on January 2, 2025, on Station Road, Portmarnock. The victim, who was a childhood school friend of Brennan, was stabbed in the back as he was getting into the passenger side of Brennan's car. The victim was hospitalised for four days following the assault, as the wound required surgery due to its proximity to his spine and vital organs. Judge Ronan Munro noted the bizarre nature of the offending and the absence of any previous convictions, which indicated that Brennan's moral responsibility was reduced. He imposed a headline sentence of five years, which was reduced to three and a half years considering Brennan's guilty plea and lack of previous convictions.
A man who raped his partner's 16-year-old sister asked why the victim hadn't screamed during the attack, a court has heard. The 24-year-old defendant, who cannot be named to protect the victim's identity, was convicted of the rape and sexual assault of the teenager at his home in August 2023. The victim, who was not present in court, prepared a victim impact statement detailing the emotional distress and self-harm she experienced following the attack. The court heard that the victim tried to shout out during the assault but found she had no voice. She later told her sister, who confronted the accused, and he denied the allegations, asking why the victim had not screamed. The victim later told her mother part of what had happened, leading to a garda investigation. The defendant, who has no previous convictions, has been in custody since his conviction in April. His defence counsel noted that the accused has a diagnosis of autism and ADHD and has not been in trouble with the law previously or since.
Seamus O'Callaghan, a retired Franciscan brother and convicted sex offender, has been jailed for 11 years for raping a teenage boy while working as a teacher in Offaly almost 30 years ago. O'Callaghan, 82, was convicted of one count of anal rape following a Central Criminal Court trial in May. The victim, who was 13 years old at the time, stated that the incident took his childhood away and caused long-term psychological damage. O'Callaghan has 11 previous convictions for indecent assault, all involving teenage boys. Mr Justice Kerida Naidoo noted the significant, long-lasting impact of the abuse on the victim's life and imposed a headline sentence of 13 years, which was reduced to 11 years due to O'Callaghan's age and medical issues. The court heard that O'Callaghan had cooperated with the investigation but his statements were found to be false self-serving denials. The case highlights the long-term consequences of sexual abuse and the importance of holding perpetrators accountable.
A self-described jihadist, Abdullah Khan, who previously inspired by Isis set fire to a pub owned by Conor McGregor and stabbed a garda in Dublin, has not cooperated with a psychologist assessing his risk. However, Khan has agreed to undergo a full assessment by a prison psychologist before sentencing. Khan pleaded guilty to eight charges, including arson, assault on a garda, and engaging in terrorist activity. The court heard that Khan was part of a wider group of like-minded radicals and that his actions were similar to terrorist attacks in Europe. Ms Justice Karen O'Connor ordered a probation report to assess Khan's radicalisation and the need for post-release supervision. The court adjourned the case to July 27 to confirm if Khan will engage with the risk assessment process. Counsel for Khan stated that he is willing to abide by the conditions set out in the probation report and undergo a full assessment by a prison psychologist.
The jury in the trial of a garda accused of raping his former wife and of child cruelty towards two of his daughters will continue their deliberations for a fourth day, after being given the option of returning a majority verdict. The 48-year-old defendant has pleaded not guilty at the Central Criminal Court to one count of child cruelty of his now 17-year-old daughter on dates between 2015 and 2024. He has also pleaded not guilty to two counts of raping his wife on dates in 2009 and 2021. He has further pleaded not guilty to two counts of child cruelty of his now 24-year-old daughter on unknown dates between 2007 and 2020. He also denies a charge of assault causing harm to this daughter on an unknown date in late 2021 to early 2022, after she had turned 18. All parties in the case have a statutory right to anonymity. The alleged offending took place at two locations in the north-west of the country where the family was living at the relevant times.
The State has dropped the charges against a man whose conviction for rape was quashed by the Court of Appeal. The man (27), who cannot legally be identified, was previously convicted of two counts of rape and one count of sexual assault at an apartment on Middle Abbey Street, Dublin 1, on February 15, 2018. Trial judge Mr Justice David Keane sentenced him to eight and a half years in prison. The Court of Appeal however quashed that conviction, finding that the trial judge had failed to warn the jury of the dangers of convicting after the complainant initially nominated another party as having sex with her and did not refer to the accused. On Wednesday, the case was listed for mention before the Central Criminal Court when lawyers for the Director of Public Prosecutions informed Mr Justice Paul McDermott that the State were entering a nolle prosequi on all counts. Mr Justice McDermott then ordered that the defendant be discharged from all counts. The man has a statutory right to anonymity.
A 41-year-old woman, Paulina Zawadzka, was jailed for two years for attacking a man after he laughed at her suggestion they should be together. The victim suffered lacerations, fractures to his elbow, little finger, and nose, and has been left with facial scars and post-traumatic stress disorder. The incident occurred in Zawadzka's home in Dublin, where the man was found bleeding heavily, and the house was covered in blood when Gardaí arrived. The court heard that the man had been homeless and living in a hostel, while Zawadzka had a good work history, including at the Shelbourne Hotel. The attack happened after the man was invited for drinks, and he believed Zawadzka was joking when she suggested they be together. However, she hit him with what he thought was a glass bottle. The assault was captured on a call to emergency services made by her flatmate, who described the ongoing violence. Zawadzka had 19 previous convictions, including three for assault. Her defense highlighted her struggles with alcoholism and her efforts to seek treatment. The unnamed 41-year-old pleaded guilty.
Gavin Hanway, of Limekiln Green, Walkinstown, Dublin, launched an appeal against his convictions for assault causing serious harm and aggravated burglary. He was previously found guilty by a jury at Portlaoise Courthouse of stabbing Kevin Kenny at a house in The Hermitage, Portlaoise, Co Laois, on July 26, 2016. Following the trial, Judge Keenan Johnson sentenced Hanway to 12 years in prison. In the current appeal, counsel James Dwyer SC argued that the seizure of Hanway's car breached his constitutional rights because the search warrant was issued in another garda's name. He also challenged the admission of evidence regarding Hanway's testosterone use, claiming it was prejudicial, and argued the jury verdict was not properly delivered under section 35(2) of the Criminal Justice Act, 1984. The State's counsel, Aoife O'Leary BL, countered that the trial judge had correctly ruled the car evidence admissible in the interests of justice despite the procedural irregularity. She further noted that the testosterone evidence was probative and that the jury was merely polled on their numbers after returning the verdict. The Court of Appeal, comprising Mr Justice John Edwards, Ms Justice Isobel Kennedy, and Mr Justice Alexander Owens, heard the arguments. The court reserved judgment in the case to a later date, meaning the matter was adjourned and not concluded.
An Offaly man, Patrick Killally, who was jailed for 11 years for the sexual abuse of two children, argued that his trial was unfair due to the admission of evidence about a third party confronting him after hearing him "roaring" at a child to come into a bedroom. Killally was convicted of multiple counts of sexual assault and rape of two boys over different periods. His defense claimed the evidence was more prejudicial than probative, as it was not related to the charges against him. The prosecution argued the evidence had probative value in discrediting Killally's claim that he had never been left to babysit the injured party. The court reserved judgment on the appeal, with the defense emphasizing the lack of evidence that Killally called the child into the bedroom and the other child's testimony that she was not abused.
The trial of Derek Boyd (31) and Chantelle Harcourt (34) continues before Ms Justice Melanie Greally and a jury. Mr Boyd, of Finglas, Dublin 11, has pleaded not guilty to murdering Mark Carroll (34) at his home on June 9, 2024. He also pleaded not guilty to threatening Ms Megan Rock with death or serious harm and assaulting her on the same occasion. The prosecution alleges Mr Boyd stabbed Mr Carroll with intent to kill or cause serious harm. The jury heard that Mr Boyd was on a suspended sentence for shooting his sister dead in a tragic accident at the time of the alleged stabbing. Ms Harcourt, of Darndale, Dublin 17, has pleaded not guilty to two counts of impeding the prosecution of Mr Boyd. She is accused of cleaning the scene before gardai arrived and acting to impede his apprehension at Blanchardstown Garda Station. Witness Garda Emer Downey testified that Ms Rock identified Mr Boyd as the attacker and described Mr Carroll returning to the house to 'sort it out' after an argument. The trial is ongoing and was not adjourned or finalised at this stage.
A High Court judge has ordered that the mother of a child rape victim be brought before him to face allegations that she filmed her daughter's abuser in court and posted it on social media. The woman is alleged to have made a video recording in court of her 17-year-old daughter's rapist and to have posted it on Facebook. The identity of the 30-year-old Carlow defendant cannot be published to protect the statutory anonymity of the victim. The man was jailed for seven years for repeatedly sexually abusing his partner's teenage niece. He had pleaded guilty to one count of sexual assault and one count of orally raping the child. The girl told the court that she was 13 when the defendant started "grooming" her. She said she has struggled with anxiety, depression, trauma, and flashbacks as a result of the abuse. Prosecuting counsel brought the case back before the Central Criminal Court seeking an "attachment order" in relation to contempt of court proceedings. The video post was viewed around 300 times but has since been taken down.
The jury in the trial of a garda accused of raping his former wife and committing child cruelty towards two of his daughters will continue their deliberations tomorrow. The 48-year-old defendant has pleaded not guilty to multiple charges, including one count of child cruelty against his 17-year-old daughter and two counts of raping his wife on dates in 2009 and 2021. He also denies charges of child cruelty against his 24-year-old daughter and assault causing harm. The alleged offenses took place in the north-west of the country, and the defendant is a serving member of the gardai on suspension. After a second day of deliberations, the judge instructed the jury to suspend their discussions for the evening and resume tomorrow. All parties in the case have a statutory right to anonymity.
John Eghomwanre and Faraj Odukoya were sentenced at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court for their roles in the St Valentine's Day violence that resulted in the death of Quham Babatunde. Eghomwanre pleaded guilty to two counts of assault causing harm to Mr Babatunde and another man. Odukoya pleaded guilty to three counts of assault causing harm to Mr Babatunde and two other men, one count of violent disorder, and two counts of burglary committed on November 23, 2023. Judge Martin Nolan imposed a five-year prison sentence on both men, backdated to the date they entered custody. The judge noted that both defendants engaged in serious violence and that Odukoya's conduct was more serious, though he acknowledged the younger defendant's age and the opportunistic nature of the burglaries. Earlier this year, co-defendants Rory Carr and Bruno Tache were each sentenced to three years and six months for assault causing harm and violent disorder, with the final 12 months suspended on strict conditions for two years. Four other men remain before the courts in relation to the incident. The court accepted that neither Eghomwanre nor Odukoya possessed a knife during the attacks.
A convicted killer, currently serving a six-year term for manslaughter, had his prison sentence extended after he rammed his former partner's car with their three children inside and then assaulted his partner's sister in front of her teenage daughter. The man pleaded guilty to assault and criminal damage, and the court considered the breach of a safety order. The judge noted the severity of the accused's actions, including ramming the car with his own children inside, and emphasized the need for control and dominance in his behavior. The sentence was made consecutive to his existing term, with the final two years suspended on strict conditions. The victims' impact statements highlighted the emotional trauma suffered by the family, including the sister who was left with severe facial injuries and the daughter who had to protect her mother. The judge commended the victims for standing their ground and ordered the accused to maintain a ten-year bond to stay away from the complainants.
A man who punched, headbutted, and choked his former partner until she nearly lost consciousness has been sentenced to two years in prison, with the final nine months suspended. The victim suffered severe bruising and experienced long-term mental health issues, including nightmares and insomnia. Jonathan Cooke, 29, pleaded guilty to assault causing harm at the woman's home in June 2024. During the attack, he ignored her pleas to stop and continued the violence. Although he claimed she had struck him first, the victim denied this. Judge Orla Crowe emphasized that the violence was a gross violation of the woman's rights and condemned the actions as unacceptable, regardless of the relationship's context. Cooke was ordered to undergo an intimate partner violence program and probation supervision. The court also noted his difficult background and current efforts to rebuild his life. The victim was given the option to accept a €1,400 token of remorse or have the money donated to a charity.
Seamus O'Hara, a 78-year-old man from Limavady, Derry, was sentenced at the Central Criminal Court to concurrent terms totalling ten years imprisonment. In March, a jury convicted him of one count of rape and 35 counts of indecent assault of a child, who was aged between six and 12, at his former family home in Donegal between 1976 and 1983. Mr Justice Paul Burns described the conduct as a "prolonged and orchestrated campaign of sexual abuse" involving grooming-type behaviour. During the sentencing, O'Hara turned to the victim and said, "shame on you," remarks the judge dismissed, stating O'Hara was the one who should be ashamed. The judge noted the severe, lasting impact on the victim, including isolation and mental health issues, while acknowledging the delay in the proceedings. In mitigation, the court considered O'Hara's age, health, and work history. O'Hara has previous convictions in Ireland and Northern Ireland for offences including assault, drink driving, and possession of a firearm. His defence counsel, James McGowan SC, stated O'Hara does not accept the verdict and requested to serve his sentence closer to Derry. The matter was finalised with the imposition of the ten-year custodial sentence.
Derek Boyd, 31, and Chantelle Harcourt, 34, are on trial at the Central Criminal Court, where both have pleaded not guilty to charges arising from an incident at a home in Dublin on June 9, 2024. Mr Boyd faces charges of murdering Mark Carroll, 34, threatening Megan Rock, and assaulting her. Ms Harcourt is accused of impeding the apprehension or prosecution of another person at the scene and later at Blanchardstown Garda Station. The jury heard from Assistant State Pathologist Dr Margaret Bolster that Mr Carroll died from a fatal stab wound to the chest, which penetrated the pericardial sac and right ventricle. She stated the injury was unsurvivable and caused haemorrhage and shock, with no contributory factors from alcohol or cocaine. Minor injuries consistent with a fight were also noted. The prosecution alleges Mr Boyd stabbed Mr Carroll with intent to kill or cause serious harm. The jury was informed that Mr Boyd was on a suspended sentence for previously shooting his sister dead in a tragic accident. The trial continues before Ms Justice Melanie Greally.
Lawyers for a garda accused of raping his former wife and committing child cruelty have told the jury that the prosecution's case is "simply incredible." The defendant, a serving garda on suspension, has pleaded not guilty to multiple charges, including rape and child cruelty. The prosecution argued that the evidence showed a pattern of behavior that crossed the line from reasonable discipline to abuse. The defense, however, questioned the credibility of the witnesses, pointing out inconsistencies in the allegations and the lack of mention of domestic violence in a letter from the accused's ex-partner. The defense also highlighted that the ex-partner had no concerns about the safety of the children and had communicated with the accused about their care. The trial continues as the jury deliberates on the credibility of the evidence and the validity of the allegations.
Detective Garda John Pirollo described being strangled by John McDonagh during an arrest at a halting site as a "deeply harrowing experience" with lasting emotional and psychological effects. McDonagh, 36, pleaded guilty to assault causing harm and was jailed for two and a half years. The court heard that McDonagh had a history of 23 previous convictions, including assault and drug offenses. During the incident, McDonagh drove at the detective, attempted to pin him between his car and a patrol vehicle, and later strangled him during a struggle. The garda suffered injuries, including bruising and difficulty swallowing. McDonagh expressed remorse, wrote a letter of apology, and offered €5,000 as a token of remorse. Judge Martina Baxter noted the seriousness of the incident and the risk to the garda's life, but took mitigating factors into account, including McDonagh's guilty plea and mental health issues. She imposed a headline sentence of four years, reduced to three-and-a-half years with the final 12 months suspended on conditions.
A man with 82 previous convictions has been jailed for four years after repeatedly kicking his former partner in the head while on bail. Lee Byrne, 28, pleaded guilty to assault causing harm at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court. The victim described ongoing medical issues, including anxiety, persistent concussion syndrome, and headaches. Byrne was on bail at the time of the incident and was later arrested. Gardai found evidence of injuries on Byrne's hands and blood on his feet. The victim detailed the assault, saying Byrne targeted her head with kicks. She was hospitalised over 20 times and is on medication for seizures and anxiety. She described the trauma and how Byrne's actions changed her life. Judge Elma Sheahan imposed a five-year sentence, with the final year suspended, and ordered Byrne to engage with the Probation Service. The judge noted the assault occurred in an intimate relationship and considered Byrne's guilty plea and remorse. Byrne's defence highlighted his history of drug addiction and psychiatric issues. Gardai confirmed the victim's injuries were severe, with significant damage to her face.
Gerard McCarthy, 64, of Clonlost, Killucan, Co. Westmeath, was sentenced at the Central Criminal Court after pleading guilty to 24 sample counts of rape and 24 sample counts of indecent assault. The offences, which occurred between 1979 and 1985, were committed against his niece, Catriona Mahon, when she was aged between seven and 13. Mr Justice David Keane imposed a sentence of seven years' imprisonment, with the final 12 months suspended on strict conditions for two years. The judge directed McCarthy to participate in a sexual offender's rehabilitation programme if deemed suitable and imposed a two-year post-release supervision order. Aggravating factors included the high degree of breach of trust, the victim's age and defencelessness, and the persistent nature of the offending. Mitigating factors included McCarthy's early admissions of guilt, his signed guilty pleas at the District Court, and his lack of previous convictions. The court acknowledged the victim's courage in coming forward after four decades of silence. McCarthy's defence counsel highlighted his cooperation, medical issues, and a letter of apology expressing shame. The judge affirmed that the shame lay solely with the convicted man and wished the victim well in her recovery.
In the Central Criminal Court, the jury heard that Derek Boyd, who was on a suspended sentence for a prior shooting, allegedly stabbed Mark Carroll to death on 9 June 2024. Boyd's partner, Chantelle Harcourt, is accused of trying to clean the scene before Gardaí arrived. Witness Megan Rock testified that she, Mark, Boyd and another person drank cocaine in Boyd's garden on 8 June, left after Boyd told them to leave, and later returned to the house to see if they could stay the night. Rock said she saw Mark running out of the house with blood on his chest. She also claimed Boyd had pulled her by the hair and threatened her. Boyd and Harcourt have both pleaded not guilty to the charges. The trial will continue tomorrow before Justice Melanie Greally and a jury.
A man in his 50s has been convicted and fined €500 for breaching a protection order, despite requesting a deferred case. The man, who resides in Dublin, pleaded guilty at Dún Laoghaire District Court to breaching a protection order made in January 2025. The order was put in place following the breakdown of his relationship with the injured party, who is his former partner. The breach occurred on March 1, when he verbally abused the injured party and put her in fear. The court heard that the man had no previous convictions and was remorseful, but Judge Conor Fottrell emphasized the seriousness of the breach and the purpose of protection orders. The man was fined €500 and given six months to pay, with the court noting that the breach, although not violent, was still a serious matter.
Brian Dunne (41) of Ringsend, Dublin 4, has been granted bail after appearing before Judge Conor Fottrell at Dún Laoghaire District Court. Dunne is accused of assaulting a Tesco worker and damaging a garda station custody area on July 5. The court heard that Dunne had no legal representation due to the ongoing solicitors' strike over legal aid rates. Garda Rob Brennan stated there was no objection to bail as Dunne was unrepresented. Dunne was ordered to stay away from Baggot Street Upper, sign on daily at Irishtown Garda Station, and be of sober habits. The case highlights the impact of the legal aid dispute on the justice system, with delays in cases and difficulties in securing legal representation. The matter was adjourned to January 4 for further proceedings.
The President of the High Court, Mr Justice David Barniville, has expressed concern over the increasing levels of violence and disruptive behavior directed at judges and court staff in Irish courts. He noted that judges are not immune to the psychological effects of hearing graphic evidence, particularly in sexual offense cases. He called for better support systems, including access to counseling, to help judges cope with the stress of their role. He highlighted incidents of judges being attacked, receiving death threats, and facing intimidation from litigants. Mr Justice Barniville emphasized that judges are human and should not be expected to endure such pressures without support. He also criticized the lack of legal protections against disruptive behavior and the exploitation of vulnerable individuals by unqualified legal advisors. A Wellbeing Strategic Action Plan aims to improve support for judges, including training on handling traumatic evidence and promoting a culture where seeking help is not seen as a weakness. He stressed the importance of public understanding of the judiciary's role to reduce stigma and improve respect for judges.
Derek Boyd, a garda accused of murdering his partner Mark Carroll, was on a suspended sentence for the manslaughter of his sister when the alleged killing took place. The Central Criminal Court heard that Boyd and his partner Chantelle Harcourt are accused of impeding the prosecution by cleaning the scene. Megan Rock, Carroll's partner, testified that the evening was initially peaceful but turned violent when Boyd and Carroll had an argument. Rock said that Boyd threatened her and tried to set his dog on her, but she managed to escape. She denied that Carroll was a violent person and said that Boyd had previously shot his sister in a tragic accident. Boyd's legal team argued that he had a suspended sentence and was aware of the consequences of any physical altercation. The trial continues with the jury considering the evidence presented, including the alleged threats and the circumstances surrounding the murder. Derek Boyd pleaded guilty.
A serial criminal, Keith Hall, was released from prison for his role in the 2012 manslaughter of Melanie McCarthy-McNamara when he committed arson and robbery in 2025. Hall had previously been sentenced to 20 years for the manslaughter, which was later reduced. The court heard that Hall was involved in events leading up to the shooting, including agreeing to throw a rock to entice people out of a house. In 2025, Hall was caught on CCTV setting a car ablaze and later robbed a Halfords store. He was identified as one of the suspects and had a history of 112 previous convictions. Judge Orla Crowe noted Hall's high risk of re-offending but acknowledged his cooperation with the Probation Service. She imposed concurrent sentences of three years and six months, with the final six months suspended on the condition that Hall engage with the Probation Service.