Courts / Limerick / Report
Appeal court gives views on prosecution's obligations at sentencing
Summary
The Court of Criminal Appeal issued a supplementary written judgment outlining the obligations of prosecution counsel at sentencing. It held that counsel must bring a judge's attention to sentencing guidance beyond that provided by the court itself, including reputable analyses of typical sentences for the offence. The court emphasised that if mitigation arguments presented by the defence are deemed insignificant or not properly mitigating, prosecution counsel should address this to the judge. The judgment was delivered in the case of Adam Fitzgibbon, a 20‑year‑old Limerick man who had appealed a 15‑year sentence for an unprovoked attack on a schoolboy. The appeal court substituted the 15‑year term with nine‑and‑a‑half years imprisonment. The court also referenced other recent appeals, including those of Kieran Ryan and a life‑sentence case, to illustrate its guidance on sentencing ranges and mitigation handling.
Who, what, where, when and why
What: Report matter: Appeal court gives views on prosecution's obligations at sentencing. Procedural stage: appeal
When:
- March 18 Hearing Or Sentence
- 2014-07-17 Publication
Why: In the supplementary judgement delivered today on the Fitzgibbon case, the CCA said it was clear the reasoning to be found in the Z Case suggested that greater assistance from the DPP is necessary in part because of the right of the DPP to appeal against a sentence on the grounds of undue leniency and in part with a view to ensuring greater consistency in sentencing. CNI source report
Case subjects
Appellant
Outcome: The appeal court substituted the 15-year sentence imposed on Fitzgibbon with a sentence of nine-and-a-half years imprisonment. On the same day as judgement was returned in Fitzgibbon, Limerick man Kieran Ryan (29) successfully appealed against the severity of the eight-year sentence imposed on him for the possession of a handgun and ammunition.
Appellant
Outcome: Kieran Ryan (29) successfully appealed against the severity of the eight-year sentence imposed on him for the possession of a handgun and ammunition. In its judgement on Ryan, Mr O'Malley said the appeal court gave guidance as to certain sentence ranges it considered appropriate for firearms offences and certain general factors which could be taken in to account when locating these offences on the scale of seriousness.
Places mentioned
- The appeal court
Topics
Related court reports
- Manager at global IT firm denies company 'lied' about position of former Irish employee
- High Court refuses to surrender Limerick man wanted for alleged human trafficking in Greece
- Tipperary man admits attempted murder
- Volunteer who said he was sacked for warning Church officials of 'rogue' relic traders can't pursue case, WRC rules
- Appearance of tips machine in cafe that pulled in €5k unexplained, tribunal notes
- 'You've to get the morning after pill': man who was 18 when he raped girl (15) gets seven years
If a fact, identity, locality or legal outcome needs review, email the newsroom with this report's details prefilled.
Email a correction request