A 55-year-old man is appealing his combined 15-year prison sentence at the Court of Appeal. He pleaded guilty at the Central Criminal Court to one count of rape and one count of sexual assault against his niece, occurring between 2012 and 2018. Ms Justice Karen O'Connor sentenced him to 11 years, with the final 15 months suspended, on October 31, 2023. This sentence is to be served consecutively to a six-year term imposed by Judge Eugene Kelly at Waterford Circuit Court on October 26, 2023, for four counts of sexual assault against the niece's sister. The man's counsel, Colman Cody SC, argued the sentences were excessive and that a greater portion should have been suspended to incentivize rehabilitation, citing mitigating factors including his guilty plea, cooperation, and personal circumstances. The Director of Public Prosecutions, represented by Vincent Heneghan SC, contended the sentences were appropriate and within judicial discretion, noting the violence of the offenses. The court reserved judgment on the appeal.
The Court of Appeal upheld a six-and-a-half-year jail sentence for Declan Donaghey, who set a garda car alight and damaged a migrant centre during a riot described as one of the gravest examples of public disorder in the State's history. Donaghey had pleaded guilty to arson, violent disorder, and criminal damage. The court heard that his actions were part of a targeted attack on gardaí who were investigating a serious criminal offence earlier that day. CCTV footage showed Donaghey igniting a garda car and damaging another, as well as throwing objects at a migrant centre. The sentencing judge had imposed a seven-and-a-half-year sentence, with the final year suspended. Donaghey appealed, arguing the headline sentence was too high and that mitigating factors were not adequately considered. The Court of Appeal rejected the appeal, noting that the arson was the first act of the night and significantly escalated the situation. The court emphasized that an attack on gardaí is an attack on society and that the headline sentence was appropriate given the unprecedented nature of the event.
Danny Heyneman, 33, pleaded guilty to murdering his mother, Annie Heyneman, and attempting to murder his father, Henk Heyneman, at their Ballyconnell home on January 11, 2025. The court heard that Annie was stabbed at least 14 times, while Henk sustained 26 sharp force wounds. Mr Justice Tony Hunt stated he would consider imposing consecutive sentences given the vicious and prolonged nature of the attacks. Defence counsel Keith Spencer BL asked the court not to impose consecutive sentences, arguing the offences arose from a single incident underpinned by mental impairment. Heyneman, who has features of depression and a history of substance abuse but no severe mental disorder, read an apology expressing deep regret. The matter was adjourned, with sentencing scheduled for June 2.
A 29-year-old man, Tomasz Rozpeda, was sentenced for manslaughter after his friend, Maciej Nowak, died from blunt force trauma during an incident on St Stephen's Day in 2023. Rozpeda had initially been charged with murder but later pleaded guilty to manslaughter. The court heard that Nowak had consumed excessive amounts of amphetamines and alcohol, but the cause of death was determined to be the result of the trauma, not the drugs. Rozpeda claimed that Nowak had become violent and self-harming, but the pathologist's report indicated that the injuries were not self-inflicted. Rozpeda had no prior convictions in Ireland, though he had three in Poland. The court heard victim impact statements from Nowak's sister and fiancée, who described the emotional devastation caused by his death. The judge noted that Rozpeda accepted responsibility and that the case fell in the medium range of culpability, with a headline sentence of between four and ten years. Rozpeda was remanded in custody until his sentencing in July.
A 41-year-old manager at a multinational company was given a community service order after assaulting his teenage au pair in a moment of insanity. The man pleaded guilty to assault and had previously been ordered to pay €9,000 for sexual harassment. The court heard that the victim was evicted from the home and faced significant distress. The victim forgave the man, describing the incident as a mistake. The court noted the age disparity and the breach of trust. The judge imposed a headline sentence of five months, reduced to four months, with 80 hours of community service. The man expressed remorse and acknowledged his inappropriate behavior. The court emphasized the need for accountability and the impact on the victim.
A Salvadoran man, Dennis Mendoza, has been jailed for 30 months after sexually assaulting a sleeping tourist in an unregistered hostel in Dublin. Mendoza, who had no previous convictions, was found guilty by a jury of the assault, which occurred in September 2021. The victim was staying in a shared room at what he believed to be a legitimate hostel when he was sexually assaulted by Mendoza. The victim awoke to find Mendoza groping him, and a second unknown male fled the scene. A substance found in the room was identified as semen, but DNA did not match the victim or Mendoza. Mendoza claimed he was in the room to close a window. His defense highlighted his difficult background and mental health issues, but the court noted his brazen lying and the lack of consent. Judge Martina Baxter imposed a 40-month sentence, with the final ten months suspended, including probation and mental health support.
A man charged with murder at a Wicklow playground has pleaded guilty to violent disorder and producing a knife during a fight. Patrick Fitzpatrick admitted to using unlawful violence and producing a knife in the course of a fight at Ballywaltrim playground in Bray. He had also been charged with the murder of William Moorehouse, but the trial for that charge has been vacated. Fitzpatrick will appear again in July for a sentencing hearing. The court heard that the incident involved multiple individuals and that Fitzpatrick's actions were part of a broader altercation. His guilty plea to the lesser charges has led to the dismissal of the murder charge for now, with the focus shifting to sentencing for the violent disorder and weapon-related offense.
A 21-year-old man, who was convicted of oral rape, attempted rape, and sexual assault when he was 17, has appealed his conviction, arguing that the victim did not clearly express a lack of consent. The appeal claims that the victim's statement about not having sex without a condom suggests she may have consented if one had been used. The victim had kissed the appellant before the incident, and the case hinges on the interpretation of consent. The trial judge had emphasized that consent must be active and that silence does not imply consent. The appeal also challenges the admissibility of a statement the appellant made during a garda interview and the lack of CCTV footage. The court has reserved judgment on the appeal, with the case awaiting a decision from the Court of Appeal.
Twin brothers Eric and Sean Farrell were found guilty of manslaughter after killing their mother's partner, Nicolae Diaconu, following allegations of abuse. The court heard that the twins stabbed Diaconu eight times and struck him with a blunt object. Both pleaded guilty, and the Director of Public Prosecutions accepted their pleas. The court was told that Diaconu had been abusive towards their mother, prompting her to seek refuge. The twins went to his home to confront him, and a violent altercation ensued. Diaconu was found with multiple stab wounds and a blunt force injury. The court acknowledged the twins' actions were in self-defense but noted the excessive violence used. Both were sentenced to a headline term of ten to 15 years, with the court considering their close relationship and the circumstances of the incident.
Patrick Pa' Ward (38) and John Pio Ward (42) are on trial at the Central Criminal Court for attempting to murder the McDonagh brothers at an unofficial halting site in Co Offaly on 21 March 2025. Patrick Ward is charged with attempting to murder Anthony McDonagh (40) and John Ward with attempting to murder Michael McDonagh (46). Both men denied the allegations, describing the accusations as "lies 100 percent" and claiming they were shocked to be named. They said they had no contact with the McDonaghs and had never left their own yards that night. Garda investigations found small black guns in Patrick Ward's shed and in John Ward's caravan, which the accused said were air guns or BB guns belonging to their children. Both accused pleaded not guilty to all charges, including possession of firearms and violent disorder, and the trial continues tomorrow before Mr Justice Paul McDermott and a jury of seven men and five women.
Stephen Barrett, a 23-year-old with 44 previous convictions, has been jailed for three and a half years for beating a 13-year-old boy with a metal pole in a 'vicious and disturbing' attack at Connolly Station. Barrett attacked the boy after allegedly being insulted by some youths, though the victim was not involved. The assault left the boy with a deep scalp laceration and caused significant psychological trauma. The court heard that Barrett's actions were unprovoked and targeted an innocent victim. Judge Martina Baxter imposed a five-year sentence, with the final 18 months suspended, and ordered probation and rehabilitation programs. Barrett expressed remorse and acknowledged his actions were unacceptable. His defense highlighted his troubled background and drug addiction, but the court emphasized the severity of the attack and its impact on the victim and his family. Stephen Barrett pleaded guilty.
A 52-year-old man from Galway was sentenced to 13 and a half years in prison for raping and sexually abusing his two younger sisters over a period spanning several decades. The man had denied the charges but was found guilty by a Central Criminal Court jury. He was convicted on multiple counts of rape, indecent assault, and sexual abuse against both sisters, with the abuse beginning when the older sister was as young as 11 and the younger sister as young as eight. The older sister delivered a victim impact statement, detailing the profound and lasting effects of the abuse on her life, including struggles with alcohol, mental health, and her relationship with her children. She credited the Irish justice system for allowing her to speak out and begin the healing process. The younger sister also shared her experience of living with shame, guilt, and mental health issues, expressing relief at finally being able to move forward.
Aaron Connolly, who was serving a life sentence for the murder of Cameron Reilly, had his conviction quashed on appeal. The Court of Appeal found that the trial judge's instructions to the jury were imbalanced and may have been perceived as advocacy for the prosecution. Mr Justice John Edwards noted that the trial judge's comments were overly emphatic and could have influenced the jury's perception. Connolly initially denied any sexual contact with Reilly but later admitted to performing oral sex on him. The trial jury heard that Reilly was bisexual and that Connolly had a history of sexual relations with others. Connolly claimed he left Reilly alive, but the prosecution argued that he was the murderer. The appeal highlighted concerns about the trial judge's comments and their potential impact on the jury. The Director of Public Prosecutions will now decide whether to seek a retrial. Aaron Connolly pleaded not guilty.
William McCarthy (38) of Carlow pleaded guilty to assaulting an Irish Rail ticket inspector and burglarizing a Carlow GAA club. The assault occurred on September 14, 2024, when McCarthy refused to show his ticket and attacked the inspector on the Waterford/Heuston line. The victim suffered injuries including a broken finger and bruising to his face and was treated in hospital. McCarthy also pleaded guilty to criminal damage and theft from the Éire Óg Clubhouse, where he had previously burgled the premises four times. The damage to the cigarette machine was estimated at €2,000, with €2,830 worth of cigarettes and vapes stolen, along with €1,520 in cash. The victim's impact statement highlighted the emotional and financial toll of the assault, including difficulties paying his mortgage and the need for counseling. McCarthy's defense argued that his actions were driven by addiction and desperation to pay off a debt. The judge remanded McCarthy in custody and adjourned sentencing until next week.
A 31-year-old man from Killeshandra, County Cavan, has received a fully suspended two-year sentence at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court for sexually assaulting a Ryanair cabin crew member during a flight to Dublin Airport. Aaron Brady pleaded guilty to the assault, which occurred approximately 40 minutes before landing. The court heard Brady had consumed approximately five bottles of wine before boarding and between 12 and 15 mini bottles during the flight. Judge Jonathan Dunphy imposed the suspended sentence on strict conditions, including probation service supervision, offence-focused work, addiction support engagement, and attendance at a residential alcohol treatment programme. Brady has paid €3,130 to cover the woman's out-of-pocket expenses and received a five-year ban from Ryanair, which Judge Dunphy noted should be for life. The woman resigned from her position following the incident and described experiencing severe emotional and psychological consequences in her victim impact statement.
A 26-year-old Dublin man has been jailed for eight years for his role in a brutal assault where he and three others attacked a victim in his home, cutting off most of his right ear with scissors and inflicting severe injuries. The victim was stripped, beaten with mirrors, ornaments, and the toilet cistern, and forced into a bathtub filled with water. The defendant, who was on bail for a previous assault, pleaded guilty to both assault causing serious harm and assault causing harm. Judge Orla Crowe described the attack as 'staggering brutality' and imposed a headline sentence of 12 years, which was reduced to eight years, with 18 months suspended. The court heard that the victim's injuries were extensive, including cuts to his face, limbs, and chest, and that the defendant was a willing participant in the attack. The ringleader received a longer sentence, while the other co-accused had already been sentenced. The victim did not wish to make a victim impact statement.
A Polish cage fighter serving a life sentence for the 2014 murder of a 23-year-old man in Co Roscommon has brought proceedings before the Court of Appeal seeking to have his conviction declared a miscarriage of justice. Leszek Sychulec, now in his 40s and previously resident in Ballymahon, Co Longford, was convicted alongside co-accused Andrzej Gruchacz in June 2016 of murdering Patryk Krupa at Athlone. The victim drowned in the River Shannon after suffering a head injury sustained during a violent assault. A jury returned unanimous guilty verdicts following five hours of deliberation, and mandatory life sentences were imposed. An earlier appeal in 2018 upheld both convictions. At a case management hearing before Ms Justice Isobel Kennedy on 15 May, Sychulec's legal representatives submitted that a miscarriage of justice arose from undisclosed material relevant to State witnesses. The court adjourned the matter to 3 July to allow the prosecution and defence to resolve disclosure issues, with an affidavit containing new evidence to be filed by 15 June. Andrzej Gruchacz pleaded not guilty.
A Brazilian national, Gabrial Fereira Motta Valladares, is facing trial on three counts of attempted murder after allegedly slashing three men in Dublin's Stoneybatter area on February 9, 2025. The accused is also charged with assault causing harm to the same men, as well as possession of a black scissors and a Tactix box-cutter knife. The trial, which is expected to last three weeks, is scheduled to begin on November 9, 2026. The case was listed for case management on July 3, 2026. Gardaí, including unarmed officers and detectives supported by Armed Support Units, responded to the incident, and the accused was initially intercepted and detained by an unarmed plainclothes garda. The charges stem from the alleged slashing-type neck wounds sustained by the victims during the attack.
Paul Kelly, 47, of Killarney, Co Kerry, was convicted at a trial in November 2024 of 12 sample counts of sexual assault, two counts of oral rape, and 12 counts of anal rape of his younger brother, Anthony Kelly. The abuse occurred between 1995 and 1999 when Anthony was aged 10 to 14. Kelly, who was 16 to 20 during the offences, denied all charges but was found guilty. He was sentenced to seven and a half years' imprisonment by Ms Justice Melanie Greally. In a subsequent appeal against conviction, counsel for Kelly argued that evidence of the complainant's statement to a witness in the "present perfect continuous tense" was unfairly admitted, as it implied ongoing abuse seven years after it ended. The State's counsel rejected this as an "academic exercise on phraseology," noting the witness had also used the past tense. The appeal court, presided over by Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy, reserved its judgment to a later date. Anthony Kelly waived his anonymity to allow his brother to be named, stating the abuse caused lifelong trauma, including suicidal thoughts and self-harm.
In an attempted‑murder trial at the Central Criminal Court, Patrick Ward (38) and John Pio Ward (42) are charged with trying to kill Anthony McDonagh (40) and Michael McDonagh (46) at an unofficial halting site in Co Offaly on 21 March 2025. Dr Chloe Doran testified that Anthony had innumerable shotgun pellet wounds to the chest, heart, lungs and major vessels, with a CT scan showing pellets in the heart, jugular vein, aorta and collapsed lungs. Michael also suffered numerous pellets in the torso, neck and chest, with a CT scan revealing pellets in the heart, neck and large arteries. Both men were treated by multiple doctors and nursing staff, monitored in intensive care, and were described as "very lucky" not to suffer serious complications or death. The accused pleaded not guilty to all charges, including possession of firearms and violent disorder.
Lee Coleman, 38, of Tyrellstown, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to robbery committed on August 23, 2020. The court heard that Coleman, who had arranged a meeting with a sex worker, demanded the return of €70 and took her phone, placing her in fear. He subsequently returned to the property, where he smashed windows and kicked the door. Coleman was later found severely beaten and bundled into a car, an incident initially reported as a possible abduction. Judge Orla Crowe acknowledged the frightening nature of the robbery but noted Coleman has not come to Garda attention since 2018 and appears to be getting his life back on track. She set a headline sentence of three years before imposing a two-year sentence. This term was suspended in full on the condition that Coleman keep the peace and be of good behaviour for three years. The judge described this as a final chance, holding the suspended sentence over him as a penalty. Coleman has 15 previous convictions, including for assault and theft. Defence counsel highlighted his subsequent sobriety and business setup, while the prosecution noted the victim's phone and money were never recovered.
Aaron McCarthy, a 33-year-old appellant, appeared before the District Court Appeals Court to challenge the severity of his five-month imprisonment sentence. He was previously convicted in the District Court of obstructing a peace officer under section 19 of the Criminal Justice (Public Order) Act, 1994. Garda Brian Kelly testified that on October 6, 2024, McCarthy refused to leave a Dublin 7 dwelling after being arrested, requiring six gardai to subdue him. Kelly noted McCarthy's history of 96 previous convictions, including criminal damage and assault. Defence counsel Seosaimhín Ní Chathasaigh BL argued that McCarthy accepts responsibility, is remorseful, and suffers from an acquired brain injury affecting emotional control. She stated he is now substance-free and willing to attend anger management courses. Judge Ronan Munro indicated he required further information before considering suspending the sentence, warning that non-compliance with conditions would render suspension pointless. Consequently, the matter was adjourned until October to allow for the preparation of a probation report. The court did not conclude the appeal at this stage, leaving the original five-month sentence in effect pending the report.
Two men who were high on laughing gas and randomly attacked a woman have been told by a judge that some crimes cannot be walked away from. The attack occurred on Seamus Ennis Road, Finglas, where the woman was pushed to the ground and assaulted. The victim suffered injuries and had her phone stolen. CCTV footage captured the attackers, identified as Craig Mains (28) and Shane Daly (27). Both pleaded guilty to assault and related charges. Judge Ronan Munro described the attack as savage and an outrage. Mains received a three-year sentence with the final 18 months suspended, while Daly received a three-month suspended sentence. Both were placed under probation supervision. The victim was commended for her resilience. The defendants expressed remorse and offered financial compensation. Mains has a history of drug use and is in treatment, while Daly is drug-free and has no recent convictions.
The trial of Patrick Ward (38) and John Pio Ward (42) continues at the Central Criminal Court, where both men have pleaded not guilty to all charges. They are accused of attempting to murder Anthony McDonagh (40) and Michael McDonagh (46), respectively, at an unofficial halting site in Kilcruttin, Co Offaly, on March 21, 2025. Both accused also face charges of possession of firearms and violent disorder. During testimony, Michael McDonagh stated he was 100 percent certain that John Pio Ward shot him in the chest with a shotgun-type gun. He described seeing a crowd of 12 to 15 men approaching the site before the incident. Under cross-examination, the defence challenged his certainty, noting he did not initially identify the shooter to gardai that night, though McDonagh denied lying to the jury. The trial is ongoing before Mr Justice Paul McDermott and a jury of 12, with proceedings scheduled to continue tomorrow.
A 38-year-old man, Gerard Cervi, who was convicted of murdering Robert Bobby' Messett at Bray Boxing Club in 2018, is appealing his conviction. His barrister, John Fitzgerald SC, argues that the trial judge made errors in admitting Facebook photos showing Cervi holding a firearm, as they were irrelevant and prejudicial. He also claims that the jury should have received stronger warnings about identifying Cervi from CCTV footage. Additionally, Fitzgerald contends that surveillance photos of Cervi in his garden and evidence from the Volkswagen Caddy van were improperly admitted. Cervi was found guilty of Messett's murder but acquitted of attempting to murder Pete Taylor and Ian Britton. The appeal hearing continues, with the State's legal team to respond to Fitzgerald's submissions. The trial judge admitted the Facebook photos based on the stance Cervi adopted, which mirrored that described by Pete Taylor. Cervi was sentenced to life imprisonment in December 2023. The unnamed 38-year-old pleaded not guilty.
Patrick Ward (38) and John Pio Ward (42), both of Kilcruttin, Tullamore, Co Offaly, are on trial at the Central Criminal Court, charged with attempting to murder Anthony McDonagh (40) and Michael McDonagh, respectively, at an unofficial halting site on March 21, 2025. Both accused have pleaded not guilty to all charges, which also include possession of firearms and violent disorder. The trial is ongoing before Mr Justice Paul McDermott and a jury of seven men and five women. During testimony, Anthony McDonagh stated he was "100% sure" Patrick Ward was the shooter, describing how Ward pointed a gun at him from a distance of up to three feet. McDonagh suffered a chest wound, a broken nose, and embedded pellets. He denied cross-examination suggestions that he was mistaken or had a motive to implicate Ward, asserting his identification was correct. Defense counsel for John Pio Ward questioned whether the shooter could have seen the victim, but McDonagh maintained his view was unobstructed. The matter was adjourned and continues tomorrow.
A man who sexually abused a teenager over 20 years ago was sentenced to 38 months in prison, with the final four months suspended. The victim, who was 16 at the time, spoke out during the sentencing, saying that the abuse had stolen his childhood and left him with lasting trauma. He described the abuse as a secret he carried for years, leading to isolation, drug use, and a damaged relationship with his mother. The court heard that the abuse occurred over a year and involved mutual touching and oral rape. The accused, who had a previous conviction for sexual assault, was convicted on ten counts of gross indecency. The judge noted the prolonged nature of the offense and imposed consecutive sentences. The victim expressed gratitude to those who supported him and said he now feels seen and heard for the first time. The unnamed 62-year-old pleaded not guilty.
A 64-year-old man was given a suspended sentence after deliberately breaching a safety order by being present in court while his former partner was a defendant. He then encouraged a violent disorder outside the Supreme Court, where up to 15 women attacked the woman. The man was not involved in the actual fighting but was shouting and encouraging the incident. The court heard that the woman was visibly distressed and suffered cuts to her face and neck. The judge emphasized that the breach of the safety order was deliberate and showed a reckless disregard for the law. The man apologized for his presence and expressed regret for his actions. Judge Orla Crowe imposed a six-month sentence, suspended in full on strict conditions, after considering his personal circumstances and the impact of the incident on the victim. The unnamed 64-year-old pleaded guilty.
A violent abuser who raped his former partner and subjected her to extreme domestic violence, including urinating on her, pouring bleach over her, and flushing her head down a toilet, has failed in his appeal to overturn his conviction. The man, who cannot be named to protect his ex-partner's identity, was convicted of 32 counts of assault causing harm, including 18 counts of assault causing harm, two counts of rape, and two counts of making threats to kill. The appeal was dismissed by Mr Justice John Edwards, who noted the victim's testimony about the degrading nature of the assaults. The defense argued that the prosecution's closing speech contained inappropriate expressions of personal opinion, but the court found that the trial judge adequately addressed these concerns. The appeal was dismissed, and the man was sentenced to 12 years in prison, with six months suspended. The victim's impact statement highlighted the lasting trauma and fear experienced during the abuse. The unnamed 53-year-old pleaded not guilty.
Edward McGregor, 55, was jailed for nine years for sexually abusing his two young cousins over eight years, from 1986 to 1993. The victims, Frances McGregor and Caitriona Carr, expressed frustration with the lengthy and difficult court process. McGregor pleaded guilty to multiple counts of sexual assault and attempted rape. Justice Eileen Creedon noted the abuse's severe impact on the victims' mental health and trust. She reduced the headline sentence of 13 years to 10 years, considering mitigating factors. The victims hope the case will lead to changes in how such cases are handled, emphasizing the need for victim support and reducing delays. McGregor's defense highlighted his lack of previous convictions and his remorse, requesting a sentence that allows for rehabilitation. The prosecution emphasized the severity of the offenses, including the breach of trust as a babysitter and the prolonged nature of the abuse.
A man who took part in a violent attack that left another man with life-changing injuries has been jailed for 10 years. Graham Dunphy, 31, pleaded guilty to assault causing serious harm to Austin Doherty, who was attacked outside a Dublin casino. The attack, which lasted 45 seconds, left Doherty with serious head injuries, including seizures, spastic paralysis on his left side, and rigidity in his legs. He required extensive speech therapy and is now dependent on a powered wheelchair. Dunphy was a constant throughout the assault, adding to the menace and terror of the event. The court heard that the victim's life has been significantly impaired, with limited improvement four years after the attack. The Director of Public Prosecutions indicated that the offence fell within the serious range of offending, carrying a headline sentence of 10 to 15 years. Judge Martina Baxter noted the ferocity of the attack and the lack of effort to contact emergency services. She imposed a sentence of 10 years imprisonment, backdated to April 20, 2026.
A Ukrainian national has been sentenced to six and a half years' imprisonment following a serious assault at a refugee accommodation centre in Dublin. The attack occurred on 31 March 2023 at Ballyogan Regional Temporary Rest Centre, when Vasyl Bolotnykov (57) struck another Ukrainian man in the face with a fire extinguisher in an unprovoked incident. The victim, in his late 50s, lost consciousness from the impact. Dublin Circuit Criminal Court heard that medical assessment was delayed significantly, with a brain scan not conducted until nine days after the assault, revealing multiple brain bleeds and a skull fracture. The victim subsequently required surgery and spent eight weeks in intensive care. Judge Martina Baxter described the assault as ferocious and noted the victim has sustained permanent neurological effects, including memory difficulties and balance problems, preventing independent work. Bolotnykov pleaded guilty to assault causing serious harm and production of an article capable of inflicting serious injury. The victim was later relocated to accommodation in County Roscommon during his recovery period.
Patrick Ward and John Pio Ward are on trial at the Central Criminal Court, having pleaded not guilty to all charges. They are accused of attempting to murder Anthony McDonagh and Michael McDonagh, respectively, at an unofficial halting site in Kilcruttin, Co Offaly, on March 21, 2025. Both men also face charges of possession of firearms and violent disorder. The trial is currently in the evidence stage, with Anthony McDonagh testifying before a jury of seven men and five women under Mr Justice Paul McDermott. McDonagh alleged that he locked eyes with Patrick Ward, who he identified as his sister's partner, before being shot in the chest with a shotgun. He claimed Ward fired a second shot towards his son while a crowd of up to 15 people descended on the site. McDonagh stated he believed he, his wife, and children were going to die. The prosecution has noted the victims knew the accused for years. The matter is ongoing, with McDonagh's evidence scheduled to continue on Monday.
A car wash owner who shouted "I am tiger" and attacked two people during a dispute over parking spaces at a south Dublin coffee dock has been given a suspended jail sentence and ordered to carry out community service. Ismail Tamar, 42, pleaded not guilty to two counts of assault causing harm and a public order offence. The court heard that the trouble began after a dispute over where a Mercedes Sprinter van had parked near a coffee truck adjoining Tamar's car wash business. The van driver told the court that Tamar approached him swearing and shouting expletives, and later pointed a high-pressure power washer directly into his face while continuing to shout abuse. Tamar was seen punching the van driver in the face, ears, and body. A friend of the van driver described seeing Tamar point the power washer at the driver before punches were thrown. Garda Colm Walsh told the court that he arrived shortly after 1.15pm and saw Tamar throwing punches through the window of a car.
Clayton McLoughlin, 19, of Ballymun, Dublin 11, was sentenced at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court for assault causing harm. He pleaded guilty to acting as a lookout during an attack at the Applegreen Service Station in Santry on September 28, 2024. The court heard that McLoughlin, then 17, stood at the door holding a hockey stick while a co-accused, who remains at large, assaulted the victim with a hurley. The victim sustained a concussion, serious eye swelling, and permanent hearing loss. Judge Jonathan Dunphy noted that while McLoughlin did not inflict the injury, he was charged on the basis of joint enterprise and armed himself, limiting the victim's chance of escape. The judge described the incident as a planned, cowardly attack linked to a drug debt, which subsequently sparked a local feud. Aggravating factors included McLoughlin's failure to assist the convulsing victim and his subsequent flight from the jurisdiction, for which he was later remanded in custody. Mitigating factors included his early guilty plea, his age at the time of the offense, and his self-reported detoxification. Judge Dunphy imposed a sentence of four years and six months, with the final 18 months suspended on strict conditions for two years. The sentence was backdated to October 2025, when McLoughlin entered custody.
Dylan Mills has been jailed for four years for burglarizing the home of an 80-year-old man and stealing vehicles. Mills, 23, has 16 previous convictions, including criminal damage, assault, and drug misuse. The court heard that Mills broke into the home of an elderly man, stole a carving knife, and later stole a car that was involved in a crash. Mills was in foster care from age 12 to 18 and has struggled with drug addiction. His defense highlighted his early guilty plea and his efforts in custody to address his issues. Judge Martin Nolan noted the mitigating factors, including Mills' remorse and his progress in custody, but warned that if he reoffends, sentences would increase. The judge suspended the final year of the sentence for one year and placed Mills under probation supervision for one year post-release.
Ethan Lacey has received a fully suspended two-and-a-half-year sentence for sexually assaulting a six-year-old girl. Lacey, 26, was found guilty of the assault, which occurred in 2022. The court heard that Lacey used sweets to distract the child before touching her. The judge noted the aggravating factors, including the child's age and the age gap between Lacey and the victim. The child was referred for counseling after the incident. Judge Sinead Ni Chulachain considered mitigating factors, such as Lacey's lack of previous convictions and his family support. The defense submitted a psychological report stating Lacey is at low risk of reoffending. The judge suspended the sentence for three years and placed Lacey under probation supervision for the same period. The court also noted that the child is undergoing therapy and showing signs of anxiety.
A Central Criminal Court judge has discharged a jury after it was revealed that some members had conducted their own internet research on a rape trial. Mr Justice Micheal Ó Higgins stated that the actions of the jurors were 'beyond regrettable' and had undermined the trial process. The trial, which involved allegations of rape, assault causing harm, and threats to kill, had been ongoing for two weeks. The jury had begun deliberations and had spent four and a half hours considering their verdict when the issue was raised. Justice Ó Higgins suspended deliberations and considered initiating contempt of court proceedings. However, the court decided not to proceed with such actions at this time. The judge emphasized that jurors must not conduct private research or access the internet for information about the case. He noted that such actions prejudice the administration of justice and are unfair to both the complainant and the defendant. The judge expressed concern that the issue arose at a late stage in the trial, causing additional stress for those involved.
A 67-year-old man who sexually abused his daughter for nearly ten years has lost an appeal in which he claimed the defence was unfairly surprised by her testimony about using a teddy bear to wipe his semen from her leg. His legal team argued that the detail emerged during the trial and the defence were not on notice of it. However, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, with Mr Justice Alexander Owens stating that the trial judge had adequately explained to the jury why the defence counsel incorrectly suggested the complainant first mentioned the teddy bear in the witness box. The judge noted that the detail did not prejudice the defence and was a common occurrence during trials. The garda who failed to record the statement was said to have made an oversight, not a deliberate omission. The man was convicted of 71 counts of rape, oral rape, indecent assault, and sexual assault in 2023 and received an 11-year prison sentence in 2024. The unnamed 67-year-old pleaded not guilty.
A court has heard how there was 'pandemonium' with shots fired and children searching for cover during an attack on an unofficial halting site in Co Offaly. Two brothers are on trial at the Central Criminal Court, charged with attempting to murder another pair of brothers at the site last year. The victims were shot in the chest, neck, and face with pellets from a shotgun embedded near vital organs. Prosecuting barrister Kevin White SC told the jury the victims were fortunate it was not a fatal shooting. Patrick Ward (38) and John Pio Ward (42) are charged with attempted murder and possession of firearms. Both have pleaded not guilty. The incident followed a violent altercation outside Tullamore Accident and Emergency Hospital, captured on CCTV, involving Michael McDonagh, his son, and three members of the accused's family. Moments later, a large group from the official Kilcruttin halting site attacked the McDonaghs' unofficial site. The group was in possession of firearms, and shots were fired, causing chaos. The victims will testify that they recognized the shooters, Patrick and John Ward.
A former scout leader who raped his cousin and abused her two sisters has failed to overturn his rape convictions after a secret letter, allegedly from a juror, claimed jury bias. The letter, which was not investigated, alleged that some jurors had prior knowledge of the case and were biased. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, stating that no material from a juror is admissible after a trial. The 63-year-old man was convicted of five of six charges, including indecent assault and rape, and received a seven-and-a-half-year sentence. The court rejected the appeal, emphasizing that the jury verdicts were unanimous and no issues were raised during the trial. The man's legal team argued that the letter should have been investigated, but the court ruled that such actions would be a contempt of court and breach jury confidentiality. The unnamed 63-year-old pleaded not guilty.
A man accused of repeatedly slapping his wife after she did not cook him dinner has been granted bail, despite telling gardai he would 'go to India and not return'. The accused, in his forties, is charged with assault causing harm under the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act. Garda James Norris stated the alleged incident occurred late at night when the man returned home intoxicated. He allegedly slapped his wife multiple times, pulled her duvet, and followed her into the kitchen, where he slapped her again, causing her to fall. The alleged victim, who was not present at the hearing, is now seeking a safety order through the Family Courts. Garda Norris opposed bail, citing the accused's flight booking to India and his potential flight risk. The defence, led by Patricia Camillon, argued the accused has strong family ties, works part-time, and cares for their children. She noted his limited English and that he had a return flight booked. The accused is willing to surrender his passport permanently and has no prior court history.
A Ukrainian man with a significant history of violence, Mykola Kaznacheiev, was jailed for five and a half years after kicking his former partner outside her workplace and threatening to cut her head off. Kaznacheiev, who had served 21 years in prison in Ukraine, pleaded guilty to assault causing harm and criminal damage. The incident occurred in June 2025 when he approached his former partner outside her workplace, kicked her in the groin, and threatened her with violence. He was arrested after a colleague intervened. Kaznacheiev's legal team argued that he was homeless and in a psychotic episode, and urged the court to consider deportation instead of imprisonment. However, Judge Elma Sheahan imposed a five-and-a-half-year sentence, noting the seriousness of the offence, the breach of trust, and the victim's ongoing fear and distress. The judge declined to suspend any part of the sentence and ordered no contact with the victim for ten years.
Closing speeches concluded in the Central Criminal Court trial of six men, aged 32 to 55, accused of familial sexual abuse. The defendants, comprising three uncles and three younger brothers of the main complainant, face a combined total of 20 charges alleged to have occurred between 1995 and 2014. All accused have pleaded not guilty. Defence counsel for Accused F, a 32-year-old facing two rape charges, argued the allegations were nonsensical and the evidence full of holes. Counsel for Accused B, a 48-year-old uncle facing three rape and one anal rape charge, highlighted reliability issues, noting his client initially faced eight counts and that the complainant did not name him in her 2017 disclosure. Counsel for Accused G, a 45-year-old uncle facing one rape charge, stated the case relies solely on the complainant's evidence, which lacks detail. Accused A, a 55-year-old uncle, faces one rape charge. Accused C, aged 34, faces 10 charges, including rape and sexual assault against the main complainant and two sisters. Accused E, aged 32, faces two anal rape charges. All charges against a seventh man, Accused D, were withdrawn by the prosecution. The trial continues with the judge's charge to the jury.
A trial involving two brothers from Offaly charged with attempted murder at an unofficial halting site has begun. Patrick Ward (38) and John Pio Ward (42) are each charged with attempting to murder two men on March 21, 2025. They also face charges of possessing firearms and violent disorder. Both pleaded not guilty. The trial is expected to last until May 21 and will be presided over by Mr Justice Paul McDermott. Meanwhile, in a separate case, defence counsel for three men accused of familial sexual abuse argued that the complainant's claims were unreliable. John Peart SC suggested the evidence was 'nonsensical' and full of holes. Hugh Hartnett SC highlighted the lack of reliability in the evidence, noting the complainant did not initially report the abuse. Marc Thompson Grolimund SC argued that the prosecution's case was weak and that the evidence lacked detail. The trial continues with the jury's charge from Ms Justice Caroline Biggs.
Jonathan Gill, aged 44 and with an address in Clontarf, Dublin, appeared before the High Court in relation to an extradition warrant issued by Belfast Magistrates' Court. Mr Gill is wanted in Northern Ireland to face charges of murder in connection with the death of Robbie Lawlor in April 2020, and possession of a firearm with intent to endanger life. His legal team sought an adjournment of the bail hearing to review documentation from State bodies covering interactions spanning two decades, received late on the previous day. Counsel indicated she was unable to advise the court on the timeframe required for this review. Mr Justice Sean Gillane adjourned proceedings to 3 June, with liberty to apply for an earlier hearing. The extradition hearing is scheduled for the same date. The defence has raised concerns regarding the admissibility of proposed evidence under EU law provisions, despite its validity under United Kingdom law.
A 24-year-old man, Gavin Lawlor, who repeatedly assaulted and coercively controlled his teenage girlfriend, including punching her for 'liking' a TikTok video, has had his original sentence tripled by the Court of Appeal. Lawlor, from Wexford, pleaded guilty to eight counts of assault causing harm and one count of coercive and controlling behaviour between March 2021 and March 2022. In April 2025, he was sentenced to two years in prison with the final 12 months suspended. However, the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) argued the sentence was unduly lenient. At the appeal hearing, the Court of Appeal agreed, overturning the original sentence and imposing a new jail term of four years with the final 12 months suspended. The court also directed Lawlor to pay €2,000 to his victim. The judge noted the repeat nature of the offending, the escalation in seriousness, and the coercive control, including removing the victim's phone SIM card and monitoring her movements. The court highlighted that Lawlor committed the second set of offences while on bail, which is an aggravating factor.
The prosecution in the case of six men accused of sexually abusing a deaf relative faces a significant challenge after the main complainant alleged that one of her brothers raped her when he was four years old. The trial in the Central Criminal Court continued with Karl Finnegan SC presenting the defence case. The six men, aged between 32 and 55, face 20 charges, with 16 related to the main complainant, who is deaf. The abuse is alleged to have occurred over 19 years, from 1995 to 2014. Accused C, one of the defendants, is charged with 10 counts of sexual abuse, including rape and sexual assault, against his older sister and two younger sisters. The charges have been significantly reduced from the original 45, with some withdrawn by the Director of Public Prosecutions. Finnegan argued that the prosecution's case has deteriorated, with changes in the alleged acts, locations, and ages involved. He highlighted the implausibility of the allegations, such as a four-year-old boy raping a seven-year-old girl, and questioned the credibility of the complainant's evidence. The unnamed 11-year-old pleaded not guilty.
Patrick O'Brien, 74, was sentenced at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court after being convicted of indecently assaulting a girl in 1990. The victim, who was 15 or 16 at the time, reported the abuse to gardai in 2022 after reading media reports that O'Brien had received a fully suspended sentence for possessing child sexual abuse material. Judge Sinead Ni Chulachain acknowledged the offence as opportunistic but noted the significant age difference between the parties. She imposed a three-year prison sentence, with the final 12 months suspended for one year to incentivise rehabilitation given O'Brien's age. The judge directed O'Brien to undergo Probation Service supervision for one year post-release and to engage in offence or victim-focused work. The court heard that O'Brien accepted the jury's verdict. The victim stated that the ordeal changed the trajectory of her life and that reporting the crime was traumatic. Defence counsel noted that O'Brien complied with conditions of his previous suspended sentence and has no other pending matters. The judge expressed hope that the verdict would provide the victim with comfort, recognising the long-term impact of the assault.
A man who killed a pensioner with an MMA-style back spin kick has been jailed for five years. Joshua Rush (25) pleaded guilty to the manslaughter of Charles McCaughley (69) at Fairview Strand, Dublin 3 on June 7, 2021. The court heard that Rush delivered a deliberate kick to the victim, who later died from a traumatic brain injury. Judge Martina Baxter described the attack as unprovoked and called Rush's actions callous. She sentenced him to six-and-a-half years in prison, with the final 18 months suspended on conditions. Rush expressed genuine remorse and has no previous convictions. His sister, the victim's closest relative, did not want to see anyone jailed for his death. Rush's defence highlighted his difficult family background and mental health issues, asking the court to consider his culpability as low.