Dublin Circuit Criminal Court sentenced Bayleigh Fox and Saoirse Richardson for the robbery and assault of a trans woman at Devil's Lane, Cabinteely. Fox, 22, pleaded guilty to robbery and assault causing harm aggravated by hatred, while Richardson, 22, pleaded guilty to robbery and assault causing harm. Judge Martin Nolan described the incident as a "savage attack" where the victim was lured to a quiet area and assaulted. The court noted the victim suffered significant physical injuries and psychological trauma, including PTSD. Although the judge found the motive regarding an Xbox unclear, he emphasized the outrageous nature of the attack on a defenceless victim. Both defendants offered mitigation, including early guilty pleas, young ages, cooperation, and participation in rehabilitative programmes for addiction. The judge acknowledged their "close to perfect mitigation" but stated they must endure prison terms. Fox was sentenced to 18 months in prison, and Richardson received a one-year sentence. The prosecution was brought under legislation introduced late last year, highlighting the hate-aggravated nature of the offence against the victim.
A 39‑year‑old man was tried at Galway Circuit Criminal Court for a single count of sexual assault that allegedly occurred on 28 October 2019 at a friend's rented accommodation in Galway. The complainant, a young woman, testified that after a night of drinks she and her friend slept in the bedroom, during which the accused allegedly touched her genital area, digitally penetrated her vaginally and rectally, and then left. She reported the incident to her mother and the Gardaí, and was examined at a Sexual Assault Treatment Unit. The accused pleaded not guilty. During cross‑examination the defence questioned the complainant's memory of the events and suggested the alleged activity was consensual, which she denied. The trial, presided over by Judge Brian O'Callaghan, is ongoing before a jury.
A man who attempted to punch a garda while being taken to Tallaght Garda Station has been sent for a probation report. Deividas Subacius (46) pleaded guilty to threatening and abusive behaviour, intoxication, and violent behaviour on 2 November last year. The court heard that Gardaí were responding to a domestic incident when they encountered Subacius outside an apartment block. He was highly intoxicated, aggressive, and shouted abuse at the officers. During the arrest, he attempted to strike a garda in the back on the way to the station, requiring eight officers to restrain him. Upon arrival at the station, it took eight Gardaí to subdue him and place him in a cell. Subacius has nine previous convictions, including eight for public order and one for assault. Judge Karen Dowling ordered a probation report and adjourned the matter to 6 March, 2026.
A Dublin man has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity to the murder of a woman in an apartment in the capital two years ago. This afternoon, Ms Justice Melanie Greally swore a jury of seven men and five women to hear the trial of Austin Mangan (53), who is charged with the murder of Maud Coffey (41) at the Horizon Building in Royal Canal Park, Ashtown, Dublin 15 on January 13, 2023. Mr Mangan, with a previous address at Hollybank Road in Drumcondra but more recently of the Beaumont area of Dublin, pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. Ms Justice Greally said the trial will begin tomorrow and is likely to last up to six days. The case has drawn significant public and media attention, given the nature of the charge and the plea. The court is expected to hear detailed evidence over the coming days as the trial proceeds. The accused's mental state will be a central focus of the proceedings, with expert testimony likely to be presented.
Peter Kelly, a former teacher at a Spiritan-run school, has been jailed for 10 years for the indecent assault of eight boys over 30 years ago. Kelly was convicted of 28 counts of indecent assault at Willow Park School, where he was accused of being one cog in a machine of systematic abuse. The victims, now in their early 50s, described the abuse as traumatic and ongoing, with some suffering from psychiatric issues, addiction, and intergenerational harm. Judge Elma Sheahan noted the bravery of the victims and the significant damage caused by Kelly. The abuse occurred in various locations, including classrooms and the school gym, and involved games such as 'The Muppet Show' where Kelly would tickle and molest the children. The victims spoke of the lasting impact of the abuse, including PTSD, insomnia, and panic attacks. Kelly's defense argued that he never owned a passport and that the school had its own disciplinary regime. The judge imposed a global consecutive sentence of 10 years, noting the lack of acceptance of the verdict by Kelly. Peter Kelly pleaded not guilty.
A 34-year-old man was jailed for 21 months after pleading guilty to harassment, trespass, breaching a protection order, and assault. The man was found to have sent hundreds of messages to his former partner through the Revolut app after she blocked him on other platforms. He also turned up unannounced at her home and caused her physical harm. The victim stated that the man's actions left a deep psychological scar and changed her life significantly. The man also assaulted his current partner after discovering he had an affair with the first victim. He was found guilty of assault causing harm and was sentenced to 21 months in prison. The judge noted the impact of the man's actions on both victims and imposed a global sentence, including a 15-year no-contact order with the first victim.
Dean Joyce, 33, was sentenced at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court after pleading guilty to one count of threatening to kill and one count of simple assault of his then partner at an address in Tallaght on November 6, 2024. The court heard that Joyce had 341 previous convictions. Prosecution evidence alleged that Joyce pursued his partner, who was eight months pregnant, outside their home while brandishing a hammer, threatening to kill her and their unborn child before forcing her back inside. He allegedly confiscated her phone until the following morning. A further count of production of an article was taken into consideration. Judge Orla Crowe described the conduct as heinous offending towards a woman in advanced pregnancy. While acknowledging Joyce's childhood deprivation and mitigating factors, the judge set a headline sentence of six years, reduced to four years. To incentivise rehabilitation and protect society, the judge suspended the final six months of the sentence, conditional on Joyce remaining under the supervision of the Probation Service during that period. Joyce has been in custody since his arrest.
Nassar Ahmed, 45, of Ennis, is appealing his murder conviction for the killing of Eoin Boylan, 32, at Gordon Drive, Cloughleigh, Ennis, on April 14, 2020. Ahmed had pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to manslaughter, claiming self-defence. However, a jury unanimously found him guilty of murder, rejecting his defence and accepting the prosecution's allegation that he stabbed Boylan three times in a "sneak attack" after inviting him to a fist fight while concealing a knife. In July 2022, Ms Justice Eileen Creedon sentenced Ahmed to the mandatory term of life imprisonment at the Central Criminal Court. During the appeal hearing, Michael Bowman SC, representing Ahmed, argued that the trial judge erred in her ruling on how certain evidence was presented, contending that the verdicts should be set aside. Conversely, Lorcan Staines SC, for the Director of Public Prosecutions, asserted that the trial judge's ruling was entirely correct. The three-judge Court of Appeal, presided over by Ms Justice Isobel Kennedy, reserved judgment and will deliver its decision at a later date. The matter was adjourned.
The DPP accepted pleas of guilty to assault causing harm from four defendants after alleged victim Barry Moore (34) refused to testify. Jason Hennessy Jr (28), Brandon Hennessy (22), Kenneth Fitzsimons (45), and Dean Fitzsimons (25) had been charged with false imprisonment and causing serious harm, offences carrying potential life sentences. The State accepted the lesser pleas, which carry a maximum ten-year sentence, on a full facts basis. Ms Justice Karen O'Connor adjourned the matter for a sentencing hearing on January 26 next year. Mr Moore, who was arrested on a bench warrant, maintained his refusal to give evidence despite warnings of a prison sentence for non-cooperation. The DPP indicated Mr Moore would be released from custody. Devon Hennessy, who previously pleaded guilty to falsely imprisoning and assaulting Mr Moore to enhance criminal gang activities, is not part of this current trial. The court will hear evidence including photographs, medical records, CCTV, and statements made to gardai, as the State seeks to admit these without cross-examination.
A jury has unanimously convicted Christopher Devine of murder, rejecting his claim that he suffered from a substance-induced psychotic disorder due to heavy cocaine and alcohol use. Devine, who shot Michael Tormey five times in the victim's front garden, argued that his mental state diminished his capacity to control his actions. However, the court accepted the prosecution's argument that Devine acted deliberately. The trial revealed that Devine had no psychiatric history and had never taken psychiatric medication. The jury rejected the defense's claim that he was too intoxicated to form an intention to kill. The judge, Ms Justice Melanie Greally, adjourned the case until December 19, when Devine will face a mandatory life sentence. The Tormey family will be invited to make statements on that date. Devine had pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to manslaughter. The trial heard conflicting expert opinions on whether Devine met the criteria for diminished responsibility or cocaine intoxication. The jury deliberated for over four hours and found Devine guilty of murder.
Serial sex offender Philip Murphy has been jailed for 15 years for the repeated rape and sexual abuse of his younger brother and two young girls over 30 years ago. The judge, Mr Justice Paul Burns, noted that Murphy represents an ongoing danger to society and ordered that he remain under post-release supervision for 10 years. Murphy was convicted of 15 counts of rape and sexual assault, and his half brother, Michael Murphy, was jailed for four years for raping one of the girls. The victims, who were all young children at the time, described the abuse as traumatic and ongoing. Murphy threatened the older girl that he would abuse her younger sister and kill her father if she did not comply with his demands. The judge emphasized that Murphy's actions were gravely wrong and that the victims were not at fault. Michael Murphy was also sentenced for raping a girl when he was around 16 or 17. The victims spoke of the lasting impact of the abuse, including mental health issues and addiction.
Ruth Lawrence, a 46-year-old defendant, was sentenced to two mandatory terms of life imprisonment for the murders of Anthony Keegan and Eoin O'Connor. The Central Criminal Court jury had previously found that Lawrence and her boyfriend, Neville van der Westhuizen, acted as a unit to lure O'Connor to their home, where he was shot. The panel also accepted that Keegan was shot by van der Westhuizen and that Lawrence was equally liable for the outcome under joint enterprise. Lawrence had pleaded not guilty to both counts of murder, which occurred between April 22 and May 26, 2014. Justice Tony Hunt handed down the concurrent sentences, backdating them to October 4, 2022, when Lawrence entered custody. The court heard four victim impact statements detailing the trauma suffered by the families, who noted Lawrence's lack of remorse and her decade-long flight to South Africa, where she changed her name and appearance. Van der Westhuizen is currently serving a 15-year sentence in South Africa for separate offenses, with an application to return him to Ireland for trial to be considered upon his release. The judge acknowledged the vindication for the families after a lengthy legal process.
The Prison Service has been ordered to pay €60,000 in compensation and find a suitable post for a prison officer, Kim Dempsey, who was left out of work with a chronic back injury following a serious assault on duty in 2017. The assault occurred at Midlands Prison in Co Laois, and Dempsey has required ongoing physiotherapy and pain management treatment. Despite re-training and promotion, managers insisted her only options were to retire or take a pay cut to become an administrative worker. Dempsey's lawyers argued that the Irish Prison Service's chief medical officer deemed her unfit for general duties but capable of an office job without a long commute. Dempsey used her leave to gain a qualification for a work training officer (WTO) post, but was not allowed to take up the Cloverhill position due to the need for regular prison office duties. The State argued that Dempsey was not medically capable of returning to any training officer or prison officer role.
The Court of Appeal has quashed the original sentence of David Hamilton and resentenced him to eight and a half years for the rape, oral rape, and sexual assault of two female relatives in Meath between 2004 and 2008. Hamilton, who pleaded guilty to the charges, had previously been sentenced to seven and a half years by Mr Justice Tony Hunt at the Central Criminal Court. The Director of Public Prosecutions successfully appealed on the grounds that the original term was unduly lenient. Ms Justice Isobel Kennedy noted the prolonged nature of the abuse and the defendant's awareness of its wrongfulness. The new sentence includes a suspended final year, with the suspension remaining in place for life. Jonathan Hamilton, David's brother, was separately sentenced to three years for one count of rape and sexual assault of the older victim in 2005, with the final six months suspended for life. The younger victim stated she was happy with the additional year added to David Hamilton's term, expressing hope to begin healing without fear.
A man with a brain injury from a meat cleaver attack, Wayne McCauley, has been jailed for 18 months for assaulting his mother by bending her finger until it broke. McCauley, 31, pleaded guilty to assault causing harm after a row with his mother, who was 63 at the time. The court was told that McCauley grabbed his mother's hand and bent her finger until it cracked, resulting in a fractured metatarsal. He was arrested and made full admissions, stating he was coming down from drugs at the time. McCauley has a long history of previous convictions, predominantly for public order and attempted robberies. His defense highlighted his brain injury and inability to deal with stress, but Judge Martin Nolan noted his long history of offending and sentenced him to 18 months. The judge acknowledged McCauley's remorse but emphasized the cruelty of the act towards his mother. The suspended sentence was given with the hope that McCauley would not hurt his mother again.
A witness testified at a murder trial about his attempts to perform CPR on the lifeless body of a 20-year-old man who was seen running into a lamppost before becoming unresponsive. David Conlon recounted how he heard a loud roar and saw the young man running before hearing a loud smack as he hit the lamppost and fell back. Conlon and his wife went out to assist the injured man, who was found lying flat on his back with his eyes wide open. Conlon's wife called 999, and the dispatcher instructed him on how to perform CPR until emergency services arrived. Patrick Murphy, 37, admitted to stabbing Jordan Ronan but pleaded not guilty to murder. The trial heard that Murphy claimed he stabbed Ronan to protect his family or property. The jury was shown evidence, including the discovery of a single stab wound to the chest, and items found on Ronan, such as Valium tablets and cannabis. The trial continues as the court examines the intent behind Murphy's actions and the circumstances surrounding the stabbing.
A gunman who claims he was taking 'industrial quantities' of cocaine when he shot his wife's brother-in-law with a submachine gun can be found guilty of manslaughter if a jury determines he had a mental disorder or was so intoxicated that he did not form an intention to kill. Christopher Devine, 44, pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to manslaughter. The court heard that the accused was suffering from substance-induced psychotic disorder, but the prosecution argued he was not mentally ill but highly intoxicated. The judge explained that the jury could find him guilty of manslaughter by reason of diminished responsibility or due to intoxication. The trial concluded with the jury beginning their deliberations, and the case will return to court on Monday.
A high‑risk sex abuser was jailed for six years after pleading guilty to raping his next‑door neighbour in April 1991. The victim, who had just returned home after surgery, was lured in by the defendant's claim of lost keys. He forced her onto a sofa, dragged her upstairs, and raped her while she was weak and in pain. She later described the assault as humiliating and traumatic, noting that the man used his own key to re‑enter his home. The defendant had prior convictions for sexual abuse of his step‑daughter, for which he served a four‑and‑a‑half‑year sentence with 16 months suspended. In the current case, the judge set a headline sentence of nine years, reduced to seven years with the final 12 months suspended, and imposed probation supervision and a no‑contact order. The sentence was back‑dated to the defendant's December 2024 arrest.
An arsonist who had his manslaughter conviction quashed by the Court of Appeal has been re-sentenced to six years in prison. Dean Boland (37) was originally jailed for eight years in March 2023 after being convicted of the unlawful killing of Ohari Viera in August 2018. Boland had broken into a Dublin residential property, stole a rucksack, and set fire to the building. Mr Viera, who was living upstairs with two others, managed to evacuate safely, but he later returned to the property for an unknown reason and did not return. The fire engulfed the building, and Mr Viera died from cardiac arrest due to smoke inhalation. The Court of Appeal quashed Boland's manslaughter conviction, stating that Mr Viera's return to the fire broke the chain of causation. The case was returned for sentencing on the counts of arson and burglary. Judge Elma Sheahan imposed a six-year sentence on Boland for arson, backdating it to December 2022. She noted Boland's 32 previous convictions and the serious nature of the offence.
A man who used an e-bike to assault a garda during a covid lockdown has been sentenced to 20 months in prison. In May 2021, Corey Plunkett (32) was outside with other men when gardai approached to disperse them under lockdown restrictions. Plunkett, on an e-bike, began circling the gardai. When a garda attempted to grab him, Plunkett swung the e-bike, striking the garda in the eye and causing a cut that required stitches. The garda made a full recovery. Plunkett was arrested and brought to Monkstown Garda Station, where he was uncooperative and assaulted the garda member-in-charge. He pleaded guilty to the assault and had a previous conviction for a 2019 street assault. His defence stated he had struggled with addictions but has since turned his life around, offering €2,000 as a token of remorse. The judge noted his history of violent behaviour and anger management issues, ordering the €2,000 to be given to the injured garda or a local charity. The 20-month sentence was imposed, with the payment intended as punishment for the defendant.
A prosecution barrister has told a Central Criminal Court jury that Christopher Devine, who is on trial for the murder of Michael Tormey, acted with a functioning mind and full intent when he fired a machine gun at his friend. Garret Baker SC argued that the accused deliberately drove to the victim's house twice and fired two bursts of five bullets, showing clear intent to kill. He dismissed the defense's claim that Devine was suffering from a mental disorder, stating that forensic psychiatrist Dr James Walsh found the accused was suffering from cocaine intoxication, not a mental illness. Baker emphasized that even if intoxicated, the accused's brain was functioning and he had a clear intention to kill. He also criticized the defense psychiatrist's findings as too vague and unreliable. The accused has pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to manslaughter. The trial continues with the jury considering whether the accused's intoxication diminished his responsibility for the act.
Slawomir Gierlowski, a convicted serial sex offender, appeared before the Court of Appeal to challenge his conviction for the May 30, 2011, attack on a young mother at Ballymount Park. Gierlowski, who maintains his innocence, was found guilty by a jury of assault causing harm, false imprisonment, and production of an article. His legal team argued that the case relied on fragile circumstantial evidence and weak forensic material, specifically DNA found on a cigarette packet and a flex. Counsel for the State countered that the evidence must be viewed cumulatively, noting that the flex bore Gierlowski's partial fingerprint and the victim's DNA, while a Marlboro box with his DNA was found near the scene despite his denial of smoking that brand. The Court of Appeal reserved its judgment on this appeal. Gierlowski's current status stems from a July 2021 sentencing where he received a further ten years consecutive to his 2018 sentence of 22.5 years (with four years suspended) for prior attacks, totaling 28.5 years. He was subsequently sentenced to an additional six years for the Ballymount Park offence. The matter remains under appeal, with the court yet to deliver its final decision on the validity of the conviction.
In a Dublin trial, Christopher Devine, aged 44, admitted to killing Michael Tormey, 49, but denied murder, pleading guilty to manslaughter. A psychiatrist, Dr John Hillery, testified that Devine suffered from a substance‑induced psychotic disorder caused by cocaine, which diminished his capacity to control himself. Hillery noted Devine's self‑reported "shovelling big shovels of shit up his nose" and erratic behaviour over 18 months of daily cocaine use. He also described Devine's paranoia, fear of being followed, and belief that a firearm had gone missing. Forensic psychiatrist Dr James Walsh disagreed, stating Devine met criteria for cocaine intoxication rather than a mental disorder. The trial, before Justice Melanie Greally and a 12‑person jury, continues tomorrow. The article does not report any verdict or sentencing. Christopher Devine pleaded not guilty.
Kassim Dembele, 28, of Clondalkin, was sentenced at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court for assaulting his girlfriend. He pleaded guilty to one count of assault causing harm to the young woman on James Joyce Street on July 30, 2023. Prosecution evidence indicated that following a minor disagreement, Dembele punched and kicked the victim to the head and body as she lay on the ground. The court heard that alcohol did not play a factor in the incident, and the victim suffered swelling, pain, and abrasions, though she has since recovered physically. Judge Orla Crowe noted that despite Dembele having no previous convictions or history of violence, his actions displayed an utter disregard and disrespect. The judge expressed concern that such an attack occurred within a previously good relationship. In determining the disposal, Judge Crowe stated that the offence had to be marked by a partly custodial sentence. She handed down a two-year sentence but suspended the final 12 months of it on strict conditions. Consequently, Dembele will serve one year in custody. The matter was finalised at the sentence stage.
A judge in the Central Criminal Court emphasized the need for more conversations about consent on social media, stating that the days of justifying sexual misconduct by claiming the victim did not fight back have passed. The judge, Ms Justice Mary-Ellen Ring, imposed a three-year sentence on a 21-year-old man for oral rape, attempted rape, and sexual assault committed when he was 17. The victim, who was also 17 at the time, described the incident as occurring in a poorly lit corner of a skatepark. The judge noted the lack of understanding of consent and the impact of the crime on both the victim and the offender. The victim's victim impact statement highlighted the trauma and delays in the legal process. The judge reduced the sentence from six years to three, considering the defendant's youth and lack of prior convictions. The case underscores the importance of consent and the need for better education on the topic.
A jury has been sworn in for the trial of a 37-year-old man charged with the murder of 20-year-old Jordan Ronan in Dublin last year. At the Central Criminal Court today, Patrick Murphy, of Drumcairn Parade, Tallaght, was charged with the murder of Jordan Ronan at Drumcairn Avenue in the early hours of July 26, 2024. The accused pleaded not guilty to the charge. Defence counsel is Ronan Kennedy SC, while the prosecution is led by Patricia McLaughlin SC. Mr Justice Kerida Naidoo said the trial is expected to finish by December 19. The trial commences tomorrow before Mr Justice Naidoo and a jury of eight men and four women. The case has drawn significant public and media attention, with the court proceedings expected to last several weeks. The accused has been remanded in custody and is expected to face a range of charges related to the incident. The court has scheduled a number of hearings over the coming weeks to ensure the trial proceeds efficiently.
Media coverage of challenges in securing a psychiatrist for the trial of Ruth Purcell Healy, accused of murdering her six-year-old son, led an Australian-based psychiatrist to offer his services, a barrister told the court. The prosecution had struggled to find a forensic psychiatrist in Ireland to assess the accused, but the overseas professional came forward after reading about the difficulties. The psychiatrist will conduct an initial assessment via video-link and is expected to complete a full evaluation by Easter, with a report by the end of May. The case has highlighted the lack of a reliable system for psychiatric assessments in Ireland, with no legal obligation for HSE-employed psychiatrists to provide such services. The judge expressed frustration with the delays and hopes for a more structured approach. The trial is expected to proceed with a possible date in June or July.
Michael Scott, a farmer who drove over his elderly aunt with a teleporter, had his manslaughter sentence reduced from six years to four years and six months on appeal. The court acknowledged Scott's remorse and lack of prior convictions but noted his "thuggish" behavior toward his aunt. The incident occurred in 2018 when Scott, who had a long-standing land dispute with his aunt, failed to keep a proper lookout while reversing across her yard. The court found that Scott's actions were negligent but not premeditated. His sentence was reduced after considering his character and the impact of the original sentence. Scott was tearful as he embraced his family following the appeal. The case highlights the complex relationship between Scott and his aunt, which had been marked by conflict and tension over land ownership.
A garda, Eoghan McGowan, who assaulted a 17-year-old boy by pouring puddle water over his tracksuit bottoms in a deliberate act of degradation, had his two-month jail sentence overturned on appeal. The incident occurred in 2023 when McGowan, in plain clothes, approached the teenager, searched him, and then poured water over his clothing, calling him names. The victim, who was in the care of the State, reported feeling humiliated and left on the street dirty. McGowan apologized and paid €5,000 in compensation. The appeal court found that the sentence was too harsh and replaced it with 60 hours of community service and an additional €5,000 payment. The judge acknowledged the severity of the act but noted McGowan's guilty plea, remorse, and lack of prior offenses. The case highlights the need for accountability within An Garda Siochana and the impact of such actions on vulnerable individuals. Eoghan McGowan had the case dismissed.
A trial is ongoing at the Central Criminal Court, presided over by Ms Justice Caroline Biggs, involving seven men accused of sexually abusing a deaf woman over a 17-year period between 1996 and 2013. The accused, comprising three uncles and four brothers, all deny the charges. The complainant is giving evidence via video-link with interpreters and an intermediary. She described alleged incidents involving Accused D, who is accused of 22 counts of abuse between 2002 and 2013 and has pleaded not guilty to 19 charges of rape and three counts of anal rape. Accused A, a 55-year-old uncle, faces one count of rape. Accused B faces eight counts of rape, oral rape, and anal rape. Accused C faces 45 counts of rape and anal rape, plus additional charges regarding two other sisters, including sexual assault and rape. Accused E faces 16 counts, Accused F faces five counts, and Accused G faces one count of rape. All defendants have pleaded not guilty or denied the allegations. The trial is set down for four months before a 15-juror panel.
A convicted murderer, Derek Wade, has been granted leave to challenge the Minister for Justice over a separate conviction in Portugal, which is affecting his ability to transfer to an open prison. Wade is serving a life sentence for the murder of Zhi Song and a five-year sentence for attempted robbery. He also received a seven-year sentence for the murder of William Cahill. A European Arrest Warrant issued by Portuguese authorities seeks his surrender to serve a two-year and four-month sentence for thefts committed in 2005. Wade's lawyers argue that the outstanding warrant has caused him prejudice in his efforts to progress within the prison system, particularly in moving to an open prison. The High Court has granted leave for a judicial review, and the case is adjourned to February. Wade's next parole hearing is in December 2026, and his legal team is seeking a decision from the Minister for Justice on transferring the Portuguese sentence to Ireland.
Lawyers for John McDonagh, a 51-year-old man serving a 24-year prison sentence for the rape and murder of a Connemara schoolgirl, have argued that advances in forensic technology could undermine his conviction. McDonagh was found guilty in 2001 of the rape and murder of Siobhan Hynes (17) at Tismeain beach. Fibres from Hynes's clothing were found on McDonagh's jumper and in his car, supporting the prosecution's case. McDonagh's legal team, led by Michael O'Higgins SC, is seeking to re-examine the forensic evidence using modern technology. They argue that the trial did not consider new testing methods and that some forensic samples were not tested. Expert witnesses will provide evidence in February, and the court is considering whether new testing could affect the outcome of the case. The appeal is based on the potential for new technology to reveal previously unseen details in the forensic evidence. The unnamed 51-year-old pleaded not guilty.
A father-of-six, Christopher Devine (44), has pleaded not guilty to the murder of Michael Tormey (49) but guilty to the manslaughter of the deceased, who was shot five times in his front garden in Ballyfermot on January 9, 2022. The trial heard that Mr Tormey suffered severe injuries, including rib fractures and partial lung collapse. The defence is expected to call a consultant psychiatrist who will testify that the accused was suffering from substance-induced psychotic disorder at the time. However, the prosecution argues that Mr Devine was not suffering from a mental disorder but was under the influence of cocaine. Detective Garda Janette O'Neill testified that she found two discharged cartridge cases in the car used by the accused. Detective Sergeant Mark Collander stated that a Heckler & Koch submachine gun, a rare firearm in Ireland, was used in the shooting. Mr Devine told gardai that he was best man at Mr Tormey's wedding but now faces the tragic reality of having shot his friend.
A judge has refused jurisdiction in the case of a man accused of sexually assaulting a 16-year-old boy in a gym changing room. Judge Karen Dowling ruled that the allegation was too serious to be dealt with at the District Court level. The incident occurred on 5 April last year, when the accused allegedly grabbed the boy's genitals over his trousers while smirking. The victim immediately informed staff, and Gardaí were contacted. CCTV footage was obtained, leading to the accused's arrest and interview. Judge Dowling stated that the seriousness of the allegation required the case to be heard in the Circuit Court. The matter was adjourned for six weeks to prepare a book of evidence. The charge relates to an incident under Section 2 of the Criminal Law (Rape) (Amendment) Act 1990, as amended by Section 37 of the Sex Offenders Act 2001.
The Central Criminal Court trial of seven men accused of sexually abusing a deaf woman over a 17-year period continues before Ms Justice Caroline Biggs. The accused, aged 32 to 55, deny all charges. Accused C (34) faces 45 counts of rape and anal rape against the complainant between 2001 and 2013, plus charges of sexual assault and rape against two other sisters. Accused A (55) is accused of one count of rape. Accused B (48) faces eight counts of rape, oral rape, and anal rape. Accused D (33) pleaded not guilty to 19 counts of rape and three of anal rape. Accused E (32) denied nine counts of anal rape and seven of rape. Accused F (32) denied five counts of anal rape and rape. Accused G (45) denied one count of rape. The complainant, giving evidence via video-link with interpreters and an intermediary, alleged repeated abuse by her brother, Accused C, including incidents when she was aged 15 and 21. She stated she told him no and felt trapped. The trial, set down for four months, is ongoing.
Patrick Byrne, a criminal with a history of violence, was jailed for six years for assaulting his girlfriend over a prolonged period and holding a blade to her throat, before sending her threats from prison to drop the charges. Byrne has 44 convictions and was previously jailed for two years and nine months for an unprovoked assault. The court heard that Byrne assaulted his then partner several times, whipping her with a broom handle, holding a Stanley blade to her throat, and threatening to slit her throat. He also smashed up the house and upended a wardrobe, causing a television to fall on her. Byrne was arrested at a later date and pleaded guilty to one count of assault causing harm, one count of production of a broom handle, and one count of making a threat to kill. While in custody, Byrne sent threatening texts to the woman, urging her to drop the charges.
A man who was shot dead in his front garden was struck by five bullets which went through his body, causing bleeding, rib fractures and partial lung collapse, a murder trial has heard. Christopher Devine (44), with an address at Convent Lawns, Kylemore Road, Ballyfermot in Dublin 10 has pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to the manslaughter of Michael Tormey (49) at Thomond Road in Ballyfermot in the early hours of January 9, 2022. The jury has heard that a consultant psychiatrist to be called by the defence will give evidence that the accused was suffering from a mental disorder called substance-induced psychotic disorder at the time. However, it is the State's case that the accused man was not suffering from a mental disorder and instead meets the criteria for cocaine intoxication. State Pathologist Dr Margaret Bolster told Garret Baker SC, for the Director of Public Prosecutions, that she carried out a post mortem on Mr Tormey's body in the Dublin District Mortuary on the day of the shooting.
A 51-year-old man who has spent 24 years in prison for the rape and murder of a Connemara schoolgirl has claimed that his conviction was a miscarriage of justice, arguing that he should have the right to retest forensic evidence. Barrister Michael O'Higgins SC launched an appeal on behalf of John McDonagh, who was found guilty in 2001 of the rape and murder of Siobhan Hynes (17) at Tismeain beach in Keeraunbeg. McDonagh, who had pleaded not guilty, was sentenced to life in prison after a three-day trial. At the Court of Appeal, O'Higgins argued that new evidence and improved forensic testing methods could cast doubt on the original conviction. He highlighted a dispute between expert witnesses regarding the forensic evidence and claimed that the State was blocking access to the samples. O'Higgins emphasized that the potential of new testing methods had not been considered during the trial and that the defence expert, Dr Clare Jarman, disagreed with the State's expert, Dr Dorothy Ramsbottom, on the reliability of DNA testing.
Stephen Carberry, 47, pleaded guilty at the Special Criminal Court to assisting an offender by helping move and dispose of the body parts of murdered teenager Keane Mulready-Woods. The prosecution entered a nolle prosequi on two further charges against Carberry, including facilitating murder for a criminal organisation and setting fire to a vehicle. Presiding judge Ms Justice Karen O'Connor directed a victim impact statement and adjourned the matter until January 19, with Carberry remanded in custody. The court also ordered a urine analysis, a prison medic letter, and an educational report. This follows last week's guilty plea by Glen Bride, 32, to assisting in the movement and disposal of the teenager's remains. In related proceedings, Paul Crosby was jailed for ten years and Gerard Cruise for seven-and-a-half years (with six months suspended) for facilitating the murder. Ged' McKenna was previously jailed for four years for assisting in cleaning the crime scene. Keane Mulready-Woods was murdered in Drogheda in January 2020, with remains discovered in Dublin and Drogheda.
The sentencing of a woman who murdered her four-year-old stepson has been adjourned until January 12 due to the child's mother being unwell. The defendant, who faces a mandatory life sentence, will be identified only by her initials to protect the anonymity of the child. The media has requested to make submissions regarding the anonymity of the accused. The defendant initially pleaded not guilty but later pleaded guilty to murder. The child's father was sentenced to seven years for endangerment and neglect. The trial revealed that the child had suffered multiple injuries, including bruises and a liver laceration, which were consistent with non-accidental injury. The case was adjourned to allow the mother to make a statement and for the media to present its submissions.
A judge has warned the family of a 23-year-old man who sexually assaulted his niece to 'stop the theatrics' in court. The man was found guilty of sexual assault in Dublin in 2023. The victim, now 17, gave an emotional impact statement, expressing her devastation and feeling abandoned by her grandmother, who supported the accused. Judge Martina Baxter criticized the family's behavior, noting that the man's family was not helping him by their actions. The judge praised the victim for her bravery and reminded her of her parents' support. The assault occurred during a family funeral when the girl was staying at her grandmother's house. The man, who has 11 previous convictions, was sentenced to two and a half years in prison. The victim suffered severe psychological effects, including hallucinations and anxiety, and emphasized the importance of coming forward with such experiences. The judge highlighted the aggravating factors, including the location of the assault and the victim's age, and stated that the family has been 'fractured' by the incident.
A 55-year-old Kerry man, Billy Burns, was sentenced to life imprisonment for the murder of his 75-year-old mother, Miriam Burns. The jury rejected his plea of not guilty by reason of insanity, finding that his actions were due to long-term drug and alcohol abuse rather than mental illness. The trial revealed that Burns had a history of violence towards his mother, including breaking her jaw. The prosecution argued that Burns lied about his movements on the day of the murder and destroyed evidence. The court heard that Miriam Burns was described as a 'wonderful' and 'hardworking' woman who was 'always glamourous' and loved to communicate with her family. The judge expressed condolences to the family and acknowledged the 'unimaginable grief' they experienced.
Two men from Carlow have been sentenced for their roles in an attack on a man after a night of drinking and drug use. Philip Moore received four years and three months in prison, with the final 18 months suspended. Shane Coady received a suspended sentence of two years and three months. The victim, Alan Rossiter, was struck, punched, and placed in the boot of a car before being told he was going to be taken up the mountains. Moore was convicted of assault and false imprisonment, while Coady pleaded guilty to assault. The court heard that Moore had previously claimed the victim attacked him, but no evidence supported this. The victim described the attack as traumatic, affecting his quality of life and leaving him in fear. Judge Eugene O'Kelly noted the aggravating factors, including the false imprisonment and the use of violence. Moore's sentence was reduced due to his remorse and efforts to address his addiction. Coady's sentence was suspended due to his guilty plea and probation report indicating he acted under Moore's influence. Philip Moore pleaded not guilty. Shane Coady pleaded not guilty.
Brendan Keating has been jailed for threatening an off-duty garda while the officer was with his infant son in a Carlow shopping centre. Keating pleaded guilty to making a threat to kill or cause serious harm to Garda Aidan Kelly and to assault and possession of a slash hook. The court heard that Keating was on a suspended sentence and had previous convictions for assault and threats. The garda described Keating as 'unpredictable and violent' and expressed concern for his family's safety. Keating's threat was made in public, and he was known to have a history of drug use and mental health issues. Judge Eugene O'Kelly noted the severity of the threat and the impact on the garda's family. Keating's sentence was seven and a half years, with 15 months suspended, resulting in an effective prison term of six years and three months. The judge acknowledged Keating's frustration with bail conditions but emphasized that threatening a garda is unacceptable.
William Donoghue has been jailed for 33 months for breaking a woman's jaw during a New Year's Eve altercation in Carlow. Donoghue was convicted of assault causing harm after punching the woman in the face. The victim, who required surgery and had her jaw wired shut for a month, described the lasting impact on her life, including difficulty eating and feeling unsafe. Donoghue claimed the woman struck him first, but the court rejected his version of events. Judge Eugene O'Kelly noted the aggravating factors, including the victim's vulnerability and Donoghue's physical strength. The judge imposed a three-and-a-half-year sentence, suspending the final nine months due to Donoghue's good family support and the Probation Service's willingness to work with him. The victim expressed that she never received an apology from Donoghue and hopes to never experience such an incident again. William Donoghue pleaded not guilty.
A drug addict with 100 convictions who used to 'roam around the city' has been jailed for three years for targeting and robbing a man in the early hours of the morning. Gerard O'Toole pleaded guilty to one count of robbery. He has 99 previous convictions, including theft, robbery, and assault. The court heard that O'Toole was on bail when he committed the offence. Judge Martina Baxter noted that O'Toole has developed insight into his offending and has maintained it. A probation report highlighted his efforts in dealing with his addiction and his remorse. The judge set a headline sentence of six and a half years but reduced it to five years, suspending the final two years for two years. O'Toole was identified on CCTV footage during the robbery, which showed a disturbing incident. His defence highlighted his difficult childhood and the impact of being placed into care.
Pawel Pisarek, a Dublin man, is pursuing a complaint under the Equal Status Act 2000 against An Garda Síochána, alleging discrimination, harassment, and victimisation based on race. He claims that on 17 March last year, Inspector Daragh Jennings at Gorey Garda Station ejected him and his son after they spoke Polish. Pisarek stated he was seeking an explanation regarding the handling of criminal complaints for theft, assault, and death threats, alleging the officer improperly used discretion to issue only an adult caution for the theft. He described the inspector as angry and racist, claiming the officer jumped from his desk and screamed at his son. State counsel Declan Harmon BL applied for the case to be dismissed as frivolous, vexatious, or made in bad faith, noting that the Garda Síochána Ombudsman's Commission (GSOC) had previously terminated its investigation into the matter. Counsel also argued the complaint was filed out of time, as it was submitted in November 2024, exceeding the six-month limit. Pisarek rejected these characterisations, challenging the inspector to a lie detector test and asserting that CCTV footage would support his account. He confirmed there was no physical contact but expressed fear of assault due to the officer's proximity. Adjudicator Louise Boyle adjourned the case, directing that evidence from the State's witnesses be heard at a later date.
The daughter of a cocaine addict who admits to killing but denies murdering his brother-in-law when he opened fire on him with a submachine gun in his front garden has told the trial that her father would think there were people in the walls who were 'coming to get him' when he took the drug and wouldn't recognise his own family. The prosecution's case is that the accused man was not suffering from a mental disorder at the time but met the criteria for cocaine intoxication. The accused, Christopher Devine, has pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to the manslaughter of Michael Tormey. Jodie Devine, the daughter, testified that her father had a cocaine issue and that he began taking the drug when she was eight or nine years old. She said that after September 2021, the accused would take cocaine four times a week. She described how her father would avoid his children and become paranoid.
A 26-year-old man from Pakistan has been jailed for 18 months for sexually assaulting a 14-year-old girl and falsely imprisoning her at a house party in Carlow. The man had pleaded not guilty but was convicted by a jury after a trial. The victim testified that the accused man attempted to lift her dress, kissed her, and tried to pull her back into the house after she tried to escape. The jury viewed video footage from the teenager's phone, which showed the men at the party and the victim's discomfort. The accused denied the allegations but was identified through CCTV footage. The victim's impact statement described the trauma she experienced, including nightmares and anxiety. The judge noted the aggravating factors, including the accused's role as the house owner and the victim's age. He imposed a three-year and six-month sentence, suspending the final two years with conditions that the man leave the jurisdiction for ten years after release. The defense acknowledged the verdict but expressed concerns about the impact on the accused's family.
A man who assaulted a former partner while naked in a hotel corridor has been given a suspended sentence. Shane McMorrow (44) of Fairways Park, Finglas, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to assault of the woman in a Dublin hotel on October 30, 2023. Judge Martin Nolan noted that the incident occurred during an argument after a dinner, with McMorrow following the woman into the corridor, naked, and attempting to drag her back into the room. The woman was left traumatised and humiliated, though the physical injuries were not serious. The judge did not believe McMorrow would reoffend and imposed a two and a half year suspended sentence on strict conditions. Evidence showed that McMorrow had previously smashed the woman's phone. The woman expressed feeling let down by the justice system and described the incident as deeply traumatic. McMorrow's defence highlighted his brain injury and his attendance at counselling, noting his remorse and current stable relationship.