Courts / Mayo / Report

Murder trial jury ask judge about self defence and intent

Summary

A jury at the Central Criminal Court has sought clarification from Ms Justice Mary Ellen Ring on self-defence and intent in the murder trial of Matusz Batiuk (33), formerly of Carrabeg Estate, Swinford, County Mayo. Mr Batiuk has pleaded not guilty to the murder of Michael McDonagh, who died following a stabbing at the housing estate on November 16, 2020. The jury asked whether self-defence and lack of intent to commit murder or cause serious harm were mutually exclusive. In response, the judge explained that if the jury were not satisfied the accused intended to kill or cause serious harm, manslaughter would be the appropriate verdict. Ms Justice Ring noted Mr Batiuk's longstanding mental health difficulties, instructing the jury to consider him as a person with that illness. The prosecution contends he deliberately stabbed Mr McDonagh with intent to kill, whilst the defence argues he acted in self-defence, believing his life was in danger. The jury is continuing deliberations.

Who, what, where, when and why

What: Report matter: Murder trial jury ask judge about self defence and intent. Charges or matters: the murder of Michael McDonagh at the housing estate on November 16, 2020, and the jury previously heard that the accused said he believed his life was in danger when he stabbed Mr McDonagh. Procedural stage: trial

When:

• November 16, 2020 Other
• 2023-03-30 Publication

Case subjects

Places mentioned

Topics

Stage Trial Violent Crime

Related court reports

• Mayo man hit brother with shovel in protracted family dispute
• Man avoids jail for sending sinister cards after murder
• Jemima Burke says trial 'like something in Middle Ages'
• Man who stabbed home attacker in self defence is cleared of murder
• Jury begin deliberating in Mayo murder trial
• Murder accused entitled to defend himself in own home, defence tell jury

Read the original CNI report