Courts / Cork / Report
Rape conviction quashed after 'excessive interventions' by trial judge
Summary
In 2020 a man was convicted of raping a 17‑year‑old in Midleton, Co Cork, and sentenced to ten years' imprisonment, three of which were suspended. He appealed, arguing that Judge Alexander Owens had made excessive interventions during his examination and cross‑examination, thereby prejudicing his evidence and rendering the trial unsafe. The Court of Appeal, led by Justice Isobel Kennedy, found that while some interventions can be necessary, Owens' repeated questioning went beyond permissible limits and likely made the trial unfair. The appeal court quashed the conviction. The defendant remains in custody, with bail conditions preventing contact with prosecution witnesses, and the case is adjourned pending the State's decision on a retrial. The appeal also addressed the admissibility of the defendant's Google searches, which the court considered irrelevant to the trial. The decision was delivered on 28 June 2022.
Who, what, where, when and why
What: Report matter: Rape conviction quashed after 'excessive interventions' by trial judge. Procedural stage: appeal
When:
- August 2017 Incident
- September 2020 Incident
- March 10 Adjournment
- 2022-06-28 Publication
Why: In a judgement delivered by Ms Justice Isobel Kennedy, it was noted that while "excessive interventions by a trial judge" were to be "depreciated" there were occasions when such interventions were "necessary in order to clarify issues, or to clarify questions asked". CNI source report
Case subjects
Appellant
Outcome: A man who was jailed for seven years for rape has had his conviction quashed today after the Court of Appeal ruled that interventions made by the judge during the trial "were likely to have rendered the verdict unsafe". A jury, however, convicted him of the offence in September 2020 and he was sentenced to 10 years' imprisonment with the final three suspended by Mr Justice Alexander Owens at the Central Criminal Court in Cork.; The man has been remanded in custody with consent to bail on condition that he does not contact prosecution witnesses on his release and signs on at his local garda station.
Places mentioned
- Court of Appeal
- Central Criminal Court
- on at his local garda station
Topics
Related court reports
- Sentence increased for predatory child rapist who groomed girls on Snapchat
- 'Predatory' sex offender's nine-year prison term too lenient, State argues
- Predator gets nine years for raping two young girls he met on Snapchat
- Rapist argues jury should not have heard about violence against his wife
- Evidence of 16 knife injuries doesn't fit with murder accused's account of self-defence, State tells jury
- A Casual Inquiry: The trial of Richard Satchwell
If a fact, identity, locality or legal outcome needs review, email the newsroom with this report's details prefilled.
Email a correction request