Courts / Ireland / Report

Gay man's challenge against State's refusal to grant him asylum is dismissed

Summary

The High Court has dismissed the appeal of an unnamed gay man who challenged a decision denying him international protection and asylum status in Ireland. The man, who arrived in Ireland from Georgia in 2018, had his application for international protection refused by the International Protection Office (IPO). His appeal to the International Protection Appeals Tribunal was upheld, and he subsequently brought judicial review proceedings in the High Court, arguing that the Tribunal's findings were irrational. The application was opposed, and Mr Justice Anthony Barr dismissed the challenge, stating that it was brought outside the legal time limits. The judge noted that the IPO found the applicant provided contradictory accounts regarding his relationships, work, and education, and made adverse findings about his knowledge of Identoba, a pro-LGBTi group. The IPO also concluded there was no well-founded fear of persecution or risk of torture if the applicant was returned to Georgia, citing Georgia as a safe country for individuals of his sexual orientation. The applicant's legal team argued the delay in bringing the challenge was due to the counsel's other commitments, but the judge found the reasons for the delay lacked detail and ruled that the court would not extend the time limit. The judge also rejected the claim that the Tribunal's decision was irrational or breached fair procedures, stating the conclusions were lawful.

Who, what, where, when and why

What: Report matter: Gay man's challenge against State's refusal to grant him asylum is dismissed. Procedural stage: appeal

When:

• 2022-04-05 Publication

Case subjects

Places mentioned

Topics

Stage Appeal

Read the original CNI report