Courts / Dublin / Report
Judge allows man challenge fine for travelling during Covid-19 restrictions
Summary
Imran Ali, an applicant with Portuguese citizenship, secured High Court permission to challenge a €2,000 fixed penalty notice issued for travelling to Portugal during 2021 public health restrictions. Mr Justice Garrett Simons ruled that Ali met the legal threshold for a full judicial review hearing, noting the case raises significant issues regarding EU citizens' rights to exit Ireland and free movement under the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. Ali claims the regulations were insufficiently clear and that the potential penalties—including a fine up to €4,000 or one month's imprisonment—are disproportionate and breach the Constitution and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU. He alleges he travelled to assist his wife and sons in extending their immigration permissions, a purpose he argues constituted a reasonable excuse. The State opposed the application for leave. The court did not finally determine the merits of the judicial review but found an adequate factual matrix existed to adjudicate the legal questions. A stay on Ali's prosecution was continued pending the outcome of his action. The matter was adjourned and will return before the court later this month.
Who, what, where, when and why
What: Report matter: Judge allows man challenge fine for travelling during Covid-19 restrictions. Procedural stage: sentence
When:
- April 2021 Hearing Or Sentence
- April 19th 2021 Other
- May 6th 2021 Incident
- April 19th Incident
- 2022-03-07 Publication
Case subjects
Applicant
Outcome: He claims a fixed penalty of €2,000 and a fine not exceeding €4,000 and/or imprisonment for up to one month, are disproportionate and in breach of the Constitution and Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU A stay was put on his prosecution pending the outcome of his action.
Places mentioned
Topics
Related court reports
- Man withdraws appeal after telling court it 'wouldn't make a difference'
- Teen with 30 convictions who stamped on assault victim's head is jailed
- Six years for on-bail offender who fractured homeless man's skull in 'cowardly' attack
- On-bail teen offender fractured homeless man's skull in unprovoked assault
- Detective tells court of 'deeply harrowing' experience of being strangled at halting site
- Violent 'monster' jailed for repeatedly kicking former partner in the head
If a fact, identity, locality or legal outcome needs review, email the newsroom with this report's details prefilled.
Email a correction request