Courts / Dublin / Report

Judge addresses Ana Kriegel jury on intent

Date
2019-06-13

Stage
Trial

Primary locality
Lucan

County
Dublin

Summary

In a trial for the murder of Ana Kriegel, Judge Paul McDermott instructed the jury that the prosecution's case hinges on the injuries inflicted on Ana, which they argue demonstrate the accused's intention to kill or cause serious injury. The jury, after more than four hours of deliberation, has been shown various exhibits, including a blood‑stained stick, gloves with Ana's blood, Tescon insulation tape found around her neck, and CCTV footage. Mr Justice McDermott explained that intent can be inferred from preparation, citing Boy A's bringing a mask and other items to the scene. He emphasized that the prosecution believes intent is established through pathology and forensic evidence, and that the natural consequence of such injuries is serious injury or death. The accused, both 14, have pleaded not guilty to murder and to an aggravated sexual assault charge. The jury will return tomorrow to continue deliberations.

Who, what, where, when and why

What: Report matter: Judge addresses Ana Kriegel jury on intent. Procedural stage: trial

When:

14th May Incident
2019-06-13 Publication

Why: He explained that an intention to kill or cause serious injury can happen in the weeks or hours leading up to an assault or at the moment of an assault. CNI source report